No Profanity *** No Flaming *** No Advertising *** No Anti Trappers ***NO POLITICS
No Non-Target Catches *** No Links to Anti-trapping Sites *** No Avoiding Profanity Filter
Pretty liberal stance Beav but I’m wondering if ultimately something like that would pass? Sometimes/always we do have to make concessions and I’m tired of spinning my wheels.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6496958 03/21/1910:07 AM03/21/1910:07 AM
Open water rat trapping is a great experience, if I had my druthers I'd take 2 weeks in April over 2 in November. One thing I do know, you're never going to get a consensus from trappers, everyone has an agenda.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6496970 03/21/1910:22 AM03/21/1910:22 AM
Open water rat trapping is a great experience, if I had my druthers I'd take 2 weeks in April over 2 in November. One thing I do know, you're never going to get a consensus from trappers, everyone has an agenda.
Absolutely spring is incredible. Wish we could get a little of both.
Addressing the other statement... What’s the most frustrating is the pettiness
Originally Posted by Steven 49er
Need more info. What happened
Our muskrat season adjustment/extension has been pigeon holed so to speak. After years of effort and more than one CC passage it’s been sent to the back of the line. Eventually it may fail?
I don’t know the technical politics. WI has a conservation Congress process that makes recommendations to the wdnr. About rule changes through public suggestions. It’s a rigorous process
Marshrat you out there?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6497647 03/22/1907:12 AM03/22/1907:12 AM
The reason for the setback was...”guys in the north never knew this change was coming” So now it’s the CCs fault someone wasn’t paying attention?? Interrupting this forward movement is simply a critical flaw in our system.
Great consideration and debate went into this proposal. Design was not/should not pit north v south. It is attempt to reinstate science and common sense our season structure. It adds and includes opportunities for those trappers in seasonal trades that don’t get the luxury of the Fall exiperience
I also heard that many stated they never heard about the prospective change. I don't know a more public way or process then using the WCC and going to the hearings etc. If the vote is not to create split zones then that is what it should be. I was one who presented the argument for returning to our traditional 3 zone system, but if there is not support for it then let us find out. If the resolution was on up for a vote any and all interested could participate and vote accordingly. By delaying the vote we don't know what the rationale for that delay is. Delay is a way of not allowing the democratic process to function. I can live with the outcome either way but it seems that for some reason we are reluctant to move forward and or take the risk if you will. The data I put together looking at temps, ice etc. to me made good sense if one is looking at access in the fall for open water rat trapping. The other benefit with the resolution was it expanded the seasons later or into the spring as well. Now there will always be debate regarding when traps should be out on the landscape spring and or fall. It gets political when we want to control whose traps are where and when. If we look at the not too distant history seasons closed much, much earlier for rats and mink. Bryce
I also heard that many stated they never heard about the prospective change. I don't know a more public way or process then using the WCC and going to the hearings etc. If the vote is not to create split zones then that is what it should be. I was one who presented the argument for returning to our traditional 3 zone system, but if there is not support for it then let us find out. If the resolution was on up for a vote any and all interested could participate and vote accordingly. By delaying the vote we don't know what the rationale for that delay is. Delay is a way of not allowing the democratic process to function. I can live with the outcome either way but it seems that for some reason we are reluctant to move forward and or take the risk if you will. The data I put together looking at temps, ice etc. to me made good sense if one is looking at access in the fall for open water rat trapping. The other benefit with the resolution was it expanded the seasons later or into the spring as well. Now there will always be debate regarding when traps should be out on the landscape spring and or fall. It gets political when we want to control whose traps are where and when. If we look at the not too distant history seasons closed much, much earlier for rats and mink. Bryce
Thanks for your effort Bryce. Muskrat and wimarshrat also put a good deal of effort in its support.
Originally Posted by bblwi
If we look at the not too distant history seasons closed much, much earlier for rats and mink. Bryce
We definitely missed the boat there. In the 40s Mathiak mentioned how we aiternated seasons to stockpile this resource....thank goodness we got away from that. Don’t forget that we are discussing a rodent with a 2 year lifespan. Yes historically we have had a protectionist attitude towards muskrats.
As opportunities increased methods evolved. Back then trappers quit when the swamp froze. However it is an indisputable fact that muskrats in under ice conditions are superior skins and growing. To ignore that fact is carelessness.
Too harvest beaver longer than muskrats is hypocrisy!
I am still here. Where do you want to start? 49ers question?
Currently, the season is set by administrative code. I have heard rumors that legislators might be interested in setting it in state statue if folks don't get this right this time. Not sure what is right or if they think the Congress has it wrong already. Lol
My gut tells me this is going legislative route.
Last edited by WIMarshRAT; 03/22/1911:53 PM.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
They just set the Fisher end date in statue last session so might as well do muskrat.
Might be time to organize a trappers day at the capital.
So all 5 of us are going to show up with 5 different thoughts on the subject. Because I'm not going to be Ok with 3 zone cluster and I can't see us In the South starting out on Nov first. And the other thing I feel that when they set a date It should be that date not the Saturday closest to that date. I know Muskrat feels that we are hindering the school kids by not opening It on a Saturday but If you want to trap then get It done.
The forum Know It All according to Muskrat
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6498685 03/23/1910:33 AM03/23/1910:33 AM
If rat season starts with beaver dates that would end most open water fall trapping in the north. And spring ice out dates are more inconsistant than ice up dates in the fall. I like Beav's suggestion. Have a wide window and leave it up to the trapper to work with the weather each year.
Steve WTA NRA
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6498695 03/23/1910:45 AM03/23/1910:45 AM
I can only see one conflict with that way. And that would pertain to public lands. One trapper wants to be the first there and catches the majority number of rats. And another trapper prefers to wait for prime late fur. But now the numbers are depleted.
Keep in mind that this has absolutely no affect on me as I only trap private ground.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6498703 03/23/1910:57 AM03/23/1910:57 AM
I guess the same could be said about coon, coyotes, fox, etc. Some people will not wait until fur is ready; it has always been the case. But I don't think the answer is to set dates so late that it eliminates the ability to open water trap in the fall. Northern fall rats sell fine.
Steve WTA NRA
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6498718 03/23/1911:19 AM03/23/1911:19 AM
I'm betting that 7 days one way or the other Isn't going to effect the degree of primness at the start of the season. 200 semi prime rats are worth more then 50 prime rats caught through the Ice. With a lot less work.
The forum Know It All according to Muskrat
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6498721 03/23/1911:22 AM03/23/1911:22 AM
I don’t like Beavs suggestion BUT I would support it. I never start on the opener anyway and always am trapping at the end. That said my only concern is the back end, I would certainly take advantage of that opportunity and put my March average against anyone’s October average any day!
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6498728 03/23/1911:29 AM03/23/1911:29 AM
I trapped rats In ND up till May 9th one year. I got a $7.00 average on those rats so they must have been pretty good. And yes there were some bit up rats but the majority were just fine. The end of the season Is where It's at end of April would work for me.
The forum Know It All according to Muskrat
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6498736 03/23/1911:41 AM03/23/1911:41 AM
I trapped rats In ND up till May 9th one year. I got a $7.00 average on those rats so they must have been pretty good. And yes there were some bit up rats but the majority were just fine. The end of the season Is where It's at end of April would work for me.
Remember the state has two season end dates for Beaver because of the two zones. Asking to follow those end dates gives us end of March in South and end of April in North. That said, does this eliminate the need for any other rules by aligning seasons? The rule about different trap sizes during difference in seasons could be eliminated, right? Anything else? Eliminates the rule about incidental muskrat/mink during the spring Beaver season.
Last edited by WIMarshRAT; 03/24/1910:09 AM.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
It seems obvious that following “Mathiak Science” is outdated and unpopular, with the years of research he failed to account for that human factor...emotions, in the form of perceived access and competition.
Originally Posted by The Beav
Because I'm not going to be Ok with 3 zone cluster .
.
Thanks for saying it out loud Beav! Somebody needed to. Why? Because if with spend our time whispering in our managers ears nothing will ever get accomplished.
Originally Posted by 8117 Steve R
If rat season starts with beaver dates that would end most open water fall trapping in the north. And spring ice out dates are more inconsistant than ice up dates in the fall.
If we asked to start the beaver season earlier then consolidate the seasons would that be more plausible? Or am I still barking up the wrong tree? HELP!
. . . And the other thing I feel that when they set a date It should be that date not the Saturday closest to that date. I know Muskrat feels that we are hindering the school kids by not opening It on a Saturday but If you want to trap then get It done.
So we've got an opener that our dipstick legislators decided to start at midnight anyway, and you continue to want your same date opener annually which could land on a school night most of the time. So the kid attends school all day, football practice after school, gets home, eats, does homework, gets gear ready, then starts setting traps at midnight.
Or the kid waits 'til the next Saturday and is greeted in the nearest public marsh by flags waving from every 'rat hut.
Pure genius, Beav. Cuts down on the competition, eh?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6500445 03/25/1909:47 AM03/25/1909:47 AM
Muskrat, if a kid is in football they would have a tough time running traps unless it was in the dark. Kid would probably have to wait until football was over, or quit sports. Might as well learn early ya can't do everything, pick your poison.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6500446 03/25/1909:47 AM03/25/1909:47 AM
So to ease your frekin mind we will have a youth opener just like turkey season. So that way Dad can have his kid set all his traps too. If a kid wants to trap then he will find a way. Just like when duck season started In the middle of the week. If you wanted to duck hunt you were In the marsh not In the class room. Kids must have changed since I was one. And we took the whole week off from school to go north to deer hunt. I feel sorry for the kids of today that can't get up at midnight to set a few rat traps.
I trapped rats In ND up till May 9th one year. I got a $7.00 average on those rats so they must have been pretty good. And yes there were some bit up rats but the majority were just fine. The end of the season Is where It's at end of April would work for me.
That one year was a long time ago. Maybe 2013 when most furs spiked @ NAFA? Today is a different day. Quit living in the past.
Last edited by handitrapper; 03/25/1912:19 PM.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6500495 03/25/1910:29 AM03/25/1910:29 AM
Just saying that rats caught as late as May are still saleable. So a April closing would be Ok. If that's living In the past so be It. I think It's called making a point.
Muskrat, if a kid is in football they would have a tough time running traps unless it was in the dark. Kid would probably have to wait until football was over, or quit sports. Might as well learn early ya can't do everything, pick your poison.
Great attitude! You must make one heck of an instructor.
Somehow, back in the 60s, I ran 50 traps in the dark, on open water and on ice, before school daily and still made the school bus at 7:00 am. Wrestling practice was after school.
You must've either been a cheerleader or in the band, eh?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6500507 03/25/1910:40 AM03/25/1910:40 AM
Everyone knows the state is not going to go away from a Saturday start so let's just let it go. It is a immovable object so any banter on it is a waste of time IMO.
Personal, I say we forget about the opener and push for the extension. When legislators naturally ask for our opinion on season dates here, we emphasis the importance of getting the close right first. If pushed, we go down the two dates for the two zones. I think the best bet for them might be something similar to MN. A Saturday closest to date for each zone that would give us a common opener some years and separate openers others.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
So to ease your frekin mind we will have a youth opener just like turkey season. So that way Dad can have his kid set all his traps too. If a kid wants to trap then he will find a way. Just like when duck season started In the middle of the week. If you wanted to duck hunt you were In the marsh not In the class room. Kids must have changed since I was one. And we took the whole week off from school to go north to deer hunt. I feel sorry for the kids of today that can't get up at midnight to set a few rat traps.
LOL!
You keep on looking out for number one, meanwhile, I'll keep on looking out for the kids. If we lose the kids, we'll lose trapping as we know it here in Wisconsin. Both of us will be dead and long gone before that happens, but I'll do everything I can to keep it alive for the kids.
Just saying that rats caught as late as May are still saleable. So a April closing would be Ok. If that's living In the past so be It. I think It's called making a point.
You would need to get Governor Evers to sign it. You are not getting an April closing in the south IMO.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6500539 03/25/1911:11 AM03/25/1911:11 AM
You keep on looking out for number one, meanwhile, I'll keep on looking out for the kids. If we lose the kids, we'll lose trapping as we know it here in Wisconsin. Both of us will be dead and long gone before that happens, but I'll do everything I can to keep it alive for the kids.
No I'm looking out for everyone. What about all the trappers who work weekends?
Just saying that rats caught as late as May are still saleable. So a April closing would be Ok. If that's living In the past so be It. I think It's called making a point.
You would need to get Governor Evers to sign it. You are not getting an April closing in the south IMO.
The only person on this forum who voted for Evers was Muskrat. LOl
The forum Know It All according to Muskrat
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: Muskrat]
#6500567 03/25/1911:34 AM03/25/1911:34 AM
[quote=Rat Masterson]Muskrat, if a kid is in football they would have a tough time running traps unless it was in the dark. Kid would probably have to wait until football was over, or quit sports. Might as well learn early ya can't do everything, pick your poison.
Great attitude! You must make one heck of an instructor.
Somehow, back in the 60s, I ran 50 traps in the dark, on open water and on ice, before school daily and still made the school bus at 7:00 am. Wrestling practice was after school.
You must've either been a cheerleader or in the band, eh?
So now your bad mouthing band members and cheer leaders. I thought It was all about the kids.
I think that the lowly rodents (rats) would be really amazed at how much turmoil is created by reasoning and learned humans about when and who should manage their harvest and resource. I have trapped in the north and south and central areas of WI with and without the three, two and single zone system I have yet to have one rat tell me I should not have a trap in that spot at that time but it sure seems a lot of trappers feel that we need political interference on this issue.
I think that the lowly rodents (rats) would be really amazed at how much turmoil is created by reasoning and learned humans about when and who should manage their harvest and resource. I have trapped in the north and south and central areas of WI with and without the three, two and single zone system I have yet to have one rat tell me I should not have a trap in that spot at that time but it sure seems a lot of trappers feel that we need political interference on this issue.
Bryce
Have any ever told you to Stop on first Saturday of March?
Rats tell us many things we just ain’t good listeners. 😁
I had a crush on a cheerleader, does that count?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6501374 03/26/1906:35 AM03/26/1906:35 AM
Thanks for all the efforts gentleman... I'm not a big fan of people that sit back and complain, when you haven't participated in trying to change the outcome. Your involvement is appreciated!
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6501448 03/26/1908:49 AM03/26/1908:49 AM
So is the general consensus 2 zones, with Hwy 64 as a boundary? Same as everything else.
Or do you think we really need 3 zones as in the past?
The general consensus is . . . there is no general consensus.
This horse was beat to death last year. I can still hear the final wails from the poor beast.
The northern guys want an early opener to at least get some open water trapping before ice up, but don't want the southern guys invading "their turf." So they want the statewide opener.
The southern guys want a later opener so 'rats can grow a bit bigger and be a bit more prime before legal harvest.
There are those who say trap when you want and open the state up early, but obviously don't trap large public marshes.
We wouldn't be in this mess if a couple of influential individuals hadn't diddled with the season dates for one reason only: greed.
The founders of the WTA worked hard to secure staggered season openers to coincide with muskrat fur primeness.
Now we play politics.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6501494 03/26/1909:29 AM03/26/1909:29 AM
The one area were most agreed was the end. I think we can go in united on extending the season. If and when legislators ask about the start, we stay we are focused on the end because that is where we could find strong consensus. We are frustrated that it continues to get lost (and even made worse) as folks bicker about the start.
But if they want to know our thoughts on season start, we lay it out very similar to what you outlined Muskrat, minus the tone. Look, if we are together at the capital, we will have each side represented. If they want to give weight to all thoughts, we propose something like MN and their two zones that may or may not start on the same weekend. If they want simplification, then we say go with a common opener across the board. If they want to give more weight to the resource, then they go with three zones. If they are willing to keep us in the loop, and bounce their ideas off us as a group, then we will defend that decision coming out as a group.
Lastly, we notify the WTA, Conservation Congress, and the FB page Wisconsin Trappers of our intentions, and encourage them to participate in this discussion.
Last edited by WIMarshRAT; 03/26/1909:33 AM.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6501496 03/26/1909:29 AM03/26/1909:29 AM
Here ya go. Simplification at its best for those who struggle interpreting calendars. Everything opens October 1, everything closes April 30. Statewide.
Have at it.
Sorry for the tone. What happened to the science and managing of wildlife.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6501508 03/26/1909:47 AM03/26/1909:47 AM
Greed? How many guys will travel from Dane county to Vilas county to trap rats?
1 zone that keeps every one on the same page no zone jumping that should keep every one happy. Fur primness? Do you really think 1 week will make that much difference In fur primness. It might have some effect if you were talking a Sept opening but starting In late Oct I can't see It.
1 zone with a Oct opening and a March 31 closing. And while were at It make It a Oct opening for all species.
The forum Know It All according to Muskrat
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6501512 03/26/1909:52 AM03/26/1909:52 AM
Muskrat, you can't always take it to the extreme. Simplification can and is a good thing many times. Many times it makes it easier to prove your point.
Our focus on extending muskrat season with beaver will start to reinforce the need for at least two zones start without ever taking a stance on the start. We get to hammer the differences across the zone and when questioned why such a big difference between the two, we note the strong differences from the top of the zone to the bottom. I doubt we can get them to go to the three zones, but they will be much more likely to go with the two zone start.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
We could do like SD did a few years ago to stop out of state trappers coming early. Set the season from December 15 till April 1st. That eliminates all most all the open water concerns and we can go anywhere we want when we want and most rats will be better. If we can't agree when to start and who should be where and when maybe we should just make it so all have the same deal. The north would lose out again if the ice gets thick and 3 foot of snow but maybe it is better than sniping over earlier rats and who is catching them.
Bryce
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6501566 03/26/1910:40 AM03/26/1910:40 AM
com·pro·mise /ˈkämprəˌmīz/Submit Learn to pronounce noun 1. an agreement or a settlement of a dispute that is reached by each side making concessions. "an ability to listen to two sides in a dispute, and devise a compromise acceptable to both" synonyms: agreement, understanding, settlement, terms, accommodation; More verb 1. settle a dispute by mutual concession. "in the end we compromised and deferred the issue" synonyms: meet each other halfway, find the middle ground, come to terms, come to an understanding, make a deal, make concessions, find a happy medium, strike a balance; More 2. accept standards that are lower than is desirable.
They tried shortening season not too long ago and there was strong pushback from the folks. Did I miss the resurgence of beaver prices and increased trapping pressure?
Last edited by WIMarshRAT; 03/26/1903:45 PM.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
The beaver season does not need to be shortened. The muskrat season needs to be extended. Two seperate issues. I think trying to combine the two will be too difficult to reach an agreement.
In todays market an earlier beaver season start might be ok, but again, why complicate the muskrat issue by matching beaver? If we do that what happens if the dnr wants to shorten the beaver season again? Muskrat dates would probably change with them.
You have to be kidding right. No one In there right mind Is going to come to WI from out of state to trap rats.
No I was not kidding, but being sarcastic. It was not intended for NR trappers it was how we could resolve when to start the season. If we waited long enough all the trapping would be through the ice and we would all be treated equally. Not saying that it is what I like, but the more we argue about it ourselves the more likely those that never trap will establish the seasons we get to use. There is a lot of discussion on this forum on how society, culture etc. has changed and is going down hill. We as trappers need to look in the mirror and recogninze we have moved right along with all we detest. Whether the seasons of the past were fair or good is not so much the question as they were in place for a generation, now we can't agree on even a start for the season time of day late alone time of year.
If you get It done then I'm betting you go to ND first. I got a place you can stay.
How much?
So do I. Had a fella from Florence stay with me a month some years back. He even brought his uncle. It’s a pleasure meeting good people. I often look forward to running into my competitors.
It started when I was nineteen, I got real brave and went up around Hurley to trap beaver. I had never caught one and off I goes. First off, I find this pond and make 2 sets walks back to my truck to be greeted by an ornery old Finn, he chews me a new one about how he trapped this pond and so on. After that I was about ready to quit there wasn’t much wind left in these sails lol. Well I bounced back and plowed forward went along and made a couple more sets. Hours later, miles back on this two track I hear a loud truck bouncin down this washboard road. Thinking here we go again? Well he’s coming and now he pulls over. Out jumps a big burly woodsman, he got beaver in the back end and knows what I’m up to. he hollers “ never seen you before, where you from”. I returns, “fond du lac and no worries cause I ain’t got a clue about these beavers”. He bellers “fond du lac? Are u nuts?” Now he’s moving towards me on the bank he’s looking around and says “ last time I passed through here this was froze...it’s ready now so grab me a trap “. A trap? I says. “Ya a trap”. Now I’m a little scared and a lot confused. So I asked which trap? He says “whichever one you got”. That special fella from Hurley caught me my first beaver in the trap he set for me. I tried to pass it on a few times too.
Ya in hindsight Mathiak mAy have micro managed some. If it was all mine I would’ve done it the same way. I have the utmost respect for his work. He used the boots on the ground for information and those were some big boots.
I also like Brian and Justin’s idea of combining the seasons. April 30 seems overdone on rats but it probably ain’t enough to worry about.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6502365 03/27/1906:34 AM03/27/1906:34 AM
Perceived failure can be hard to swallow. It’s frustrating when well intentioned ideas meet peer resistance. Sometimes do we try too hard to get it right? I guess if we were really on point and listening this would have finally moved forward. As an author of the resolution I realized that some edits are in order. I believe that may be all that’s needed to move this along and keep the process away from our capital?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6502380 03/27/1907:08 AM03/27/1907:08 AM
Don't give up buddy. This resistance pales in comparison to the resistance we met up with in '89-'91 during the pursuit of mandatory trapper ed and its funding sources. At least you're not getting the angry phone calls and letters in the mail, 'course that was pre-internet too.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: bblwi]
#6502483 03/27/1909:45 AM03/27/1909:45 AM
You have to be kidding right. No one In there right mind Is going to come to WI from out of state to trap rats.
No I was not kidding, but being sarcastic. It was not intended for NR trappers it was how we could resolve when to start the season. If we waited long enough all the trapping would be through the ice and we would all be treated equally. Not saying that it is what I like, but the more we argue about it ourselves the more likely those that never trap will establish the seasons we get to use. There is a lot of discussion on this forum on how society, culture etc. has changed and is going down hill. We as trappers need to look in the mirror and recogninze we have moved right along with all we detest. Whether the seasons of the past were fair or good is not so much the question as they were in place for a generation, now we can't agree on even a start for the season time of day late alone time of year.
Bryce
So far I have yet to see any season structure from you. What do you think will work.
Has anyone called Shawn yet? He would be the first to call to get his input.
Beav, Bryce, myself, muskrat and wimarshrat were all instrumental in the “3 zone cluster” We really can’t take and don’t deserve the credit tho. It was based on the recommendations of a Wisconsin scientist Harold Mathiak. Who spent 20+ years studying the little buddies.
Nimzy , just want to say I very much appreciate what you and others have done in trying to this going. After years of thinking about it but not making it enough of a priority, i attended the spring hearings last year for the first time largely in part because of the muskrat season proposal . I dont plan on missing them in the future and and have been encouraging other family and freinds to start attending as well . Im curious do you know or does anyone else here know how how long we had a three zone mink/ muskrat season structure in place for ? Meaning about when was it implemented? I dont recall ever hearing or reading a starting timeframe for that. You mention Mathiaks influence- so was it from like the early 1950sor 60 when it started- Up until about 2012 when it was done away with?
Beav, Bryce, myself, muskrat and wimarshrat were all instrumental in the “3 zone cluster” We really can’t take and don’t deserve the credit tho. It was based on the recommendations of a Wisconsin scientist Harold Mathiak. Who spent 20+ years studying the little buddies.
Keep workin brother.
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Shawn would have the exact season dates for how long the the 3 zone season was in effect but my best guess would be roughly 30 years, maybe more. The DNR archives would have the exact dates as to when implemented and when the season changed to a two zone system, prior to becoming statewide opening. The proposal we put together through the fur harvest committee is public and therefore that information can be accessed quite easily I presume. It should be in the hearing info as a WCC advisory question. As stated by Nimzy we offered our proposals at 3-4 counties and when we met at the WCC fur harvester committee the three basic similar proposals were melded into what you will have in front of you in April. I also spoke at the WCC executive or leadership meeting regarding our proposal as I was told that would enhance our chances of moving forward. This was my first go round with working with resolutions. How this goes will be up to the trappers who vote for it or against it. The part that upsets me the most is we chose to utilize the public system that we have and the implications by some is that we are trying to sneak this past an unaware group. Can't get much more public than the system we have to utilize. Bryce
Last edited by bblwi; 03/28/1909:02 AM.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6504315 03/29/1910:47 AM03/29/1910:47 AM
Don't give up buddy. This resistance pales in comparison to the resistance we met up with in '89-'91 during the pursuit of mandatory trapper ed and its funding sources. At least you're not getting the angry phone calls and letters in the mail, 'course that was pre-internet too.
Another 3 days wouldn't get you any or much open water around here. Another week or so Is what we need.
How much open water do you want?
this enough? March 15 2019. 20+ inches of ice on the bays in Unit 4.
This whole thing started about 10 years ago. Peach and I were just plain frustrated how we had to quit right as the nicest rats we produced all season were starting to come out. It didn't make sense to either of us. We decided to try a citizens resolution to address the problem. Originally we chose NOT to go for open water because we feared it could meet fierce resistance. We selected March 31 because we believed it offered good opportunity with an equal probability of frozen or open conditions, In other words, some years you may get a couple days of open water and the next year get none.. We uncovered a phobia of a March harvest.
Have those sentiments towards a spring season changed?
Fast forward to this version. Its a copy of our old science brought back to life, zones and all. Good common sense stuff. However, We failed to consider the people factor. Perhaps season structures are more subjective than objective? A message has been sent by this going back to Advisory.
Seems like today the concern has shifted to the front end and zones?
Under the rules of the CC is it possible to revisit and edit this proposed rule change to make it more pliable?
Last edited by nimzy; 03/30/1911:15 AM.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505193 03/30/1901:52 AM03/30/1901:52 AM
It would be nice if it could get extended a bit. I was walking along the shoreline of a pond Thursday night looking for beaver dens. I came up on some muskrat entrances that I sure would have liked to have been able to set. A week ago the ice was such that I couldn't even get in the water.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505255 03/30/1907:31 AM03/30/1907:31 AM
Another 3 days wouldn't get you any or much open water around here. Another week or so Is what we need.
How much open water do you want?
this enough? March 15 2019
This whole thing started about 10 years ago. Peach and I were just plain frustrated how we had to quit right as the nicest rats we produced all season were starting to come out. It didn't make sense to either of us. We decided to try a citizens resolution to address the problem. Originally we chose NOT to go for open water because we feared it could meet fierce resistance. We selected March 31 because we believed it offered good opportunity with an equal probability of frozen or open conditions, In other words, some years you may get a couple days of open water and the next year get none.. We uncovered a phobia of a March harvest.
Have those sentiments towards a spring season changed?
Fast forward to this version. Its a copy of our old science brought back to life, zones and all. Good common sense stuff. However, We failed to consider the people factor. Perhaps season structures are more subjective than objective? A message has been sent by this going back to Advisory.
Seems like today the concern has shifted to the front end and zones?
Under the rules of the CC is it possible to revisit and edit this proposed rule change to make it more pliable?
Class is open gentlemen, shift your paradigms
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505327 03/30/1909:29 AM03/30/1909:29 AM
Well It looks to me that the trapper created open water. I want to be able to put the boat In and trap rats. Not run around On unsure Ice and chop or chain saw holes In the Ice.
The forum Know It All according to Muskrat
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505345 03/30/1909:52 AM03/30/1909:52 AM
Gary, then use the front end of the season! Great care was made to ensure ample time was provided across all zones for open water access on the front of the season.
I have said it before, but what is opportunity for some is a risk for the rest of us? What starts as your advantage, becomes a disadvantage. Can ensuring open water every year do this that we are trying to avoid?
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
Well It looks to me that the trapper created open water. I want to be able to put the boat In and trap rats. Not run around On unsure Ice and chop or chain saw holes In the Ice.
You were/are missing out. If Wisconsin had a true open water spring season, sadly most would miss out on the tremendous opportunity late ice offers Stuck in the paradigm.
My buddy calls winter the separator season.
I'm sure it's been brought before but what happens if one asks for too much?
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505404 03/30/1910:47 AM03/30/1910:47 AM
Now you sound like some Politician. What risk? And what are we trying to avoid?
It seems that all this posturing Is about saving the threatened Rat population. If you aren't smart enough to start and finish when the fur Is trappable you shouldn't be In the marsh. This last week the ice on my marsh was so honeycombed that you couldn't get on It and 2 weeks before that you would out using the chain saw or the spud to trap rats. And that Isn't cutting It for the younger generation and us old guys. That may be just fine for you guys with a size 44 shirt and a size 3 hat but that isn't going to cut It for the rest of us.
And 49er wears a size 50 shirt and I'm not to sure about his hat size, LOL
I'm going to start next week on my ADC rat work and I'm betting that those rats will be the best rats of the year.
The forum Know It All according to Muskrat
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505411 03/30/1910:55 AM03/30/1910:55 AM
Gary, not every spring is like this one . Our beaver season closes may 12. It's entirely possible there are areas won't see ice out, next year we may see an April 10th ice out. You take the bad with the good.
WHT you are trying to avoid is not building consensus, of course I sound like a politician let's face it that's how the process works. I think I could push a 2 or three week extension on rats here in MN I ask for six I'll get laughed out of the building. Politics
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: Dirt]
#6505446 03/30/1911:24 AM03/30/1911:24 AM
We just wanted access to better rats before the weight loss.
Beav I agree it can be a very difficult period for mobility within the marsh. Every year is different. I am sure that there was a window of great opportunity between your close and that honeycomb stage you experienced.
It seems that all this posturing Is about saving the threatened Rat population. If you aren't smart enough to start and finish when the fur Is trappable you shouldn't be In the marsh. This last week the ice on my marsh was so honeycombed that you couldn't get on It and 2 weeks before that you would out using the chain saw or the spud to trap rats. And that Isn't cutting It for the younger generation and us old guys. That may be just fine for you guys with a size 44 shirt and a size 3 hat but that isn't going to cut It for the rest of us.
And 49er wears a size 50 shirt and I'm not to sure about his hat size, LOL
I'm going to start next week on my ADC rat work and I'm betting that those rats will be the best rats of the year.
Let's address this. How many rats do you think could have been caught in the two previous week that the ice went from good to bad? 1000? 2000?
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505473 03/30/1911:42 AM03/30/1911:42 AM
We just wanted to trap some better rats before the weight loss.
Amazing isn't it?
You already have a season that opens too early, that should be enough to appease the open, then ask for a minor adjustment on the back end brings out the cake and eat crowd. It's too bad for the boat people types they missed out on a great opportunity all these years.
Keep plugging along brother, it won't get done if you dont. Tell everyone you're doing it for the future generations, maybe that will work
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
You miss the point I don't want to bust holes In the ice. I don't wear a size 44 shirt. But being a trapper I do wear a size 4 hat. LOL
You know what the rolling Stones say about that.
It's too bad you didn't want to bust ice, being locked in that rut probably cost you 20,0000 rats over your lifetime, that figure is an under exaggeration btw
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6505481 03/30/1911:47 AM03/30/1911:47 AM
It's too bad for the boat people types they missed out on a great opportunity all these years.
Respectfully disagree, I think its too bad for the size 3 hat types....they are the ones getting denied.
Steve I appreciate your valuable input, If you would ever decide to attempt a stunt like this in MN i'll have your back!
Originally Posted by Steven 49er
Let's address this. How many rats do you think could have been caught in the two previous week that the ice went from good to bad? 1000? 2000?
Realistically I may be the only person on this forum that can.
You know the last time Peach and I rat trapped till the end of March was like 2012, The Refuge was full that year and we took some 4000 in March. Needless to say the swamp was over that hump and it was out of our hands...…..the rats ate it down anyway.
"the loss from insufficient trapping will not be obvious, and it is easy to assume that there is no waste when muskrats are underharvested." Harold Mathiak
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6506464 03/31/1910:24 AM03/31/1910:24 AM
I never ask another trapper #s as I think its rude so thank you for sharing. The average trapper is so stuck in his mindset that open water is the only time it limits them to a fraction of the season and I thank the good lord it does. It gives more opportunity to the size 3 hat types like us. Winter is a grand time of year to be out and about. I'll put 300 miles plus on the sled ice fishing the next two weeks. Oh, how I look forward to it. I can imagine how much opportunity there is in the banana belt where you reside or southern MN for that matter during March, no disrespect intended. Up here in God's country we will hit the ideal weather for the set you pictured above in a week or so, have to anchor for beaver though lol. It'd be a blast.
Maybe if someone would write a book it would open some minds....................
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6506517 03/31/1911:17 AM03/31/1911:17 AM
You boys do understand that their is a Conservation issue when it comes to spring trapping animals? There also is a lost opportunity (not just to trap) to harvest the annual surplus the later in fall the opener begins. Fall harvest is on rats that most likely will die before spring. Spring harvest is on rats that will most likely breed if not trapped. There are exceptions.
Who is John Galt?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6506531 03/31/1911:26 AM03/31/1911:26 AM
I also understand that for the current proposal the participation rates will be so low any impact will be minimal as it will be generally still be iced over or in the transition stage.
Let us explore the exceptions. Is it possible added pressure could help the species in circumstances?
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6506548 03/31/1911:36 AM03/31/1911:36 AM
I don't know. By spring is the damage to habitat already done if you let them eat themselves out of house and home all winter? You are doing an overpopulated population a favor by thinning it in November by March it may be too late?
I suppose thinning the population in spring should help the remaining rats survival?
Fall harvest is on rats that most likely will die before spring.
In my experience the muskrats in our marshes do quite well over winter. They spend there days below an ice covered coat of armor. In fact, They lay around, gorge themselves and get fat. Do most animals under stress gain weight? Yes on rare occasion I have seen isolated areas of runners. Thank goodness it’s isolated and rare. The amount of sign in Spring is another indication of how well rats do over winter.
I’m definitely contrarian towards the attitude that untrapped muskrats suffer heavy losses over winter.
My concern comes with the summer dry. A muskrat out of water is vulnerable.
By spring is the damage to habitat already done if you let them eat themselves out of house and home all winter? You are doing an overpopulated population a favor by thinning it in November by March it may be too late?
I suppose thinning the population in spring should help the remaining rats survival?
Agreed. The damage gets done over winter. To preserve vegetation start early and go hard. Keep in mind that Fall muskrats, during the house building stage, have a limited range that will make many inaccessible.
Took a drive today with my youngerst daughter looking at the areas I trap. We spotted many rats in areas with open water flow. Many of the marshes still had ice, but the edges look to open soon. Although ive never had the opportunity to trap this time of year, it looks as though it would be fun and rewarding.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6507244 04/01/1907:03 AM04/01/1907:03 AM
Deer fly, Kinda humbling ain’t it? Where do they all come from?
If you’re anything like me, your excitement will shine on through and leave a lasting impression on your daughter. Mine blames me for her biology choices. Couldn’t be prouder:) I can’t think of a more interesting place then a wakening wetland on a sunny early spring day. Pass it on buddy!
Dirt I so enjoy a good technical discussion about muskrats. Thanks!
I also understand that for the current proposal the participation rates will be so low any impact will be minimal as it will be generally still be iced over or in the transition stage.
Let us explore the exceptions. Is it possible added pressure could help the species in circumstances?
You mean like spring beaver? What happens when it gains popularity like the spring beaver season?
Last edited by WIMarshRAT; 04/01/1908:29 AM.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass...it's about learning to dance in the rain!
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6507302 04/01/1908:33 AM04/01/1908:33 AM
I also understand that for the current proposal the participation rates will be so low any impact will be minimal as it will be generally still be iced over or in the transition stage.
Let us explore the exceptions. Is it possible added pressure could help the species in circumstances?
You mean like spring beaver? What happens when it gains popularity like the spring beaver season?
What are we talking about here? A true open water season? It that is the case there will be added pressure. But than again your spring beaver trapping can't be overly popular, if it was there shouldn't be a large need for APHIS
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6507423 04/01/1911:12 AM04/01/1911:12 AM
i don't know why dates were missing as when we were 4 the fur harvest committee and the WCC exec board those discussions had dates. I would have to look to see if dates were listed when it was voted on in 2018. I thought that it did but I would have to check. I don't know if dates were forgotten or were purposely left off. Now that we have had to advisory votes of well over 2/3rds in favor at least we should hear what those who finalize these resolutions have to say.
I can remember having dates at the original county meetings and the fur committee meetings and the exec council. I large in favor vote with that much ambiguity regarding dates speaks volumes.
If the 3 zone does move forward I tend to believe that finding common ground on fall opening dates will be easier to find than closure dates in the spring. It will probably take more pressure and effort to be able to lengthen the spring season as from what I learned with talking with individuals there was more interest in the opening dates as open water trapping is what is driving much of this effort.
What humors me is MY perception resource utilization to its full potential....so many never had the privilege to handle the *"greasy" March rats, I reckon what we don't know wont hurt us.
*….."greasy" around min 46 NAFA marsh to mainstreet..
Im growing tired:( Disappointment would be an understatement.
What humors me is MY perception resource utilization to its full potential....so many never had the privilege to handle the *"greasy" March rats, I reckon what we don't know wont hurt us.
*….."greasy" around min 46 NAFA marsh to mainstreet..
Im growing tired:( Disappointment would be an understatement.
If the 3 zone does move forward I tend to believe that finding common ground on fall opening dates will be easier to find than closure dates in the spring. It will probably take more pressure and effort to be able to lengthen the spring season as from what I learned with talking with individuals there was more interest in the opening dates as open water trapping is what is driving much of this effort.
Bryce
Originally Posted by Steven 49er
Good luck Nimzy cause you're gonna need it.
Originally Posted by Dirt
Pull up a bar stool!
Irony is i don't even fall trap. Working on behalf of all the road type workin fellas who cant trap till deer season. you know us size 2 hat types. Forgive my agenda and frustration,
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: Dirt]
#6521887 04/20/1908:13 AM04/20/1908:13 AM
The 3 zone return has been the only recent attempt at expanding the spring season that I am aware of. My statement regarding where the emphasis may lie is not that I am not in favor of extensions in the spring it is where the public and trapper sentiment and interest lies. If we can engage in discussion about the fall we can also engage in discussion about the spring.
Rat season should open state wide Oct 15th and close April 30th. With in those dates let the trapper decide when to start and when to finish.
Ours here in the southern area of the province is oct 25-apr30
Well look at that. Your season in Ontario, doesn’t start until the 25th. Yet Wisconsin’s northern trappers complain that they miss out on open water fall trapping. How on earth can you handle all that ice?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6521985 04/20/1910:24 AM04/20/1910:24 AM
I would be happy with the start dates in Ontario. Southern Ontario is further south than most of WI. The start date in Ontario for latitudes similar to northern WI is October 15, I believe.
Steve WTA NRA
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6521995 04/20/1910:36 AM04/20/1910:36 AM
Brian, you may not know this but coonwild probably lives south of Minneapolis and the majority of rats caught in Ontario are most likely caught south of Minneapolis.
Here are season tables for Ontario. I thank the good lord every day I don't have to read Ontarios regulation pamphlet more than once a decade. What a cluster!
Muskrat
1 to 35, 38 to 41
October 5 to May 15 in the year next following.
15.
Muskrat
36, 37, 42 to 67, 69B
October 15 to April 30 in the year next following.
16.
Muskrat
68, 69A, 70 to 95
October 25 to April 30 in the year next following.]
The number above the season dates are the wildlife management units they fall under.
Last edited by Steven 49er; 04/20/1910:40 AM.
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon". Milton Friedman.
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6522032 04/20/1911:45 AM04/20/1911:45 AM
Nimzy I used to scrap. I may have got many things accomplished working with and through others. It takes a toll. Hard on the family. Because I was somewhat successful, because of tireless effort, guys used to call to try to drag me into their scraps. I turned them down. The last major effort I did was present the area biologist's biological information to board of game because he wanted me to. I think he was ordered not to? Most of the fence sitters that benefit from all your effort really don't deserve what you may accomplish anyway. I may be jaded; sitting here on my bar stool.
My advice, walk away and enjoy your life, unless you enjoy all the scrapping.
Last edited by Dirt; 04/20/1911:47 AM.
Who is John Galt?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6522037 04/20/1911:54 AM04/20/1911:54 AM
Geez Dirt that’s depressing. Unfortunately I understand your position.
49er you got it right. There is a bunch of really cool/productive trapping as the thaw kicks in. That Nafa grader said something along the lines of the best rats are the ones caught with clear leather that are still greasy. Greasy rats are fat. Once it opens up it’s almost shocking how fast the rats loose that weight.
It’s an overlooked period. Some states restrict individuals from witnessing it. And other states are so easy that guys just wait for open water. Both cases loose. Mho
I’m really into the resource! It would take a book to explain it throughly.
Hay guys in Pa it closes in the second week in January......jk
Ya. That makes perfect sense. Harvest almost until they become most desirable. Wasn’t that long ago Wisconsin shared this idiocy. Thankfully we’re moving forward.
I suppose they trap beaver till May tho? Somehow we convince ourselves that biologically a beavers reproduction dynamics and lifespans are more sustainable to harvest pressures. Lmao.
Hay guys in Pa it closes in the second week in January......jk
Ya. That makes perfect sense. Harvest almost until they become most desirable. Wasn’t that long ago Wisconsin shared this idiocy. Thankfully we’re moving forward.
Pa got flush toilets yet?
We are talking about pa short season. At least I was.
Who is John Galt?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6522446 04/21/1905:25 AM04/21/1905:25 AM
You seem to always think the most profitable trapping is when each furbearer is at peak fur growth. Not always. Profit has to do with lots of variables. Muskrat trapping can be much more profitable when they are not at their best.
No, I understand how much easier/productive open water trapping can be. I also understand a percentage of trappers are either unwilling or uneducated in effective under ice methods. I certainly don’t want to restrict fall open water access.
What puzzles me is being denied the opportunity to partake in harvesting our best rats. In the case of PA, January. What kinda damage to the resources, though trapping, could possibly occur in January or February? Here in Wi it’s probably 1% of active trappers harvesting in late winter. Likely less. At least that was the reason given when they simplified our Regs and did away with our March 15 close on the old Winnebago block.
There is an even better story in a Canadian province where the season is open in fall and spring and closed in winter. Wildlife management analytics. .
Manitoba changed it's season when the prices were high '12 or so. it was because some overzellious fellows went and set and pulled and left hundreds of open huts in the dead of winter -40c/f. They would not even stop and cover a house, one pull and go. In a marsh 1000A and out in two days. A marsh that size should have had 4000 maybe 300 were pulled the rest froze out. So they closed the season 1 Dec to 15 March....the province has re-twigged the dates several times since, southern zone closes 31 April now. Once open water starts and the rats are out and about the fat reserves are used up fast and the leather goes yellow opaque in a week and sheeding pdq then.
There is an even better story in a Canadian province where the season is open in fall and spring and closed in winter. Wildlife management analytics. .
Manitoba changed it's season when the prices were high '12 or so. it was because some overzellious fellows went and set and pulled and left hundreds of open huts in the dead of winter -40c/f. They would not even stop and cover a house, one pull and go. In a marsh 1000A and out in two days. A marsh that size should have had 4000 maybe 300 were pulled the rest froze out. So they closed the season 1 Dec to 15 March....the province has re-twigged the dates several times since, southern zone closes 31 April now. Once open water starts and the rats are out and about the fat reserves are used up fast and the leather goes yellow opaque in a week and sheeding pdq then.
Seems like a knee jerk reaction to a situation that could have been handled far more appropriately.
Sound familiar WI? Zone jumping? Common opener?
MN? NR issue?
Emotions lead to dumb decisions???
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6523143 04/22/1907:49 AM04/22/1907:49 AM
Nimzy the NR issue is strategic. It has a lot to do with limiting competition. It is a question of ownership of the resource and if NR have any rights to another State's citizens resource .Especially when considering limited opportunity animals. For example: draws or seasonal limits. It can also have conservation and economic issues.
You can make it emotional like the reciprocity regulations.
As far as Minnesota the only dumb decision IMO was to take it to court.
Who is John Galt?
Re: Stalled o’muskrat
[Re: nimzy]
#6523271 04/22/1911:36 AM04/22/1911:36 AM
Western Iowa streams look like shallow dribbles of hog confinment sewage. A rat in his right mind would'nt and could'nt live in these once productive rat streams. As scarce as rats are should bring $10. But FFG says there is a lot of rat carry over from past seasons.
We have the 3 zone season this fall with the extended spring seasons as well. We too in my area are very dry and many places with fair to good rat numbers the last 3 years have been dry since June. Rivers are down about a foot as well, maybe more. I testified in favor or restating the multipe zone seasons 3 different times. I believe we started in 2016- or 2017 so 5-6 years to make that change. Bryce