Which trap is better, they seem like that same trap but the 11 is bulkier so why not just use 1.5? Can someone help explain the benefit of an 11

Better for what? Both have advantages for specific critters.

Muskrat mink fox coon I see that the CS is easier to bed for fox and coon but why not use a CS for mink and rats too

The #11 Long Spring is an amazing little trap. I've heard of trappers, here on the forum, that have caught and held coyotes in them.

I personally wouldn't purposely set one for a coyote but an incidental catch is always welcome.

Perfect trap for fox or coon sized animals, and have taken untold numbers of mink and muskrats.

Long spring traps are easier to bed SOLIDLY, and are easier for young or 'very old' hands to set.


Charlie

Duke 1 1/2 coil really shines In the rat marsh and Is also a good coon trap. And I wouldn't hesitate to use It on the fox line.

I meant to say #1 instead of 1.5

Sent you a pm
Question have you taken a trappers Ed class?

Yes I’ve taken a trappers Ed class

Excellent...great way to start. I believe the rest of the guys here would agree....you’ve got to try the different traps sets staking systems etc to get a feel for what works for you in your area.
Also try to get another experienced Ohio trapper to take you out on his line to better experience the different systems in use.

Will do. I know this old retired trapper but he’s kinda mean and whiny but I’ll try my luck...

Must be talking about Hal Sullivan....lol

LOL MChewk.
Mason, get a finger caught in a No. 11 and report back how it held.


Zim

I think if an elephant could get it's toe in an 11 it would hold it.

Mike before I scrolled down to your post I thought of Hal also!

Always stake for the biggest critter you may have in your trap..


Zim

Common knowledge that a duke #1 1/2 CS will hold an elephant if staked properly.

If you are mostly going for raccoons on dry land, I would use the #11s. 1 1/2 coil good for everything else.

Depends. What kind of soil?

I think a blue bucket set would be best though.

I’ve said too much...

Funny story, a few years back, (ok 30 or so) I'm driving into work and notice an elephant in a corn field.
It's been a good ten years or more since I fooled around with serious mind altering drugs so I shake it off.
A quarter mile later there is another one in the road with a bunch of folks trying to round it up.
Turns out they escaped from the circus world museum in Baraboo where my office is.