Home

Weather men are idiots.

Posted By: jbyrd63

Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 01:48 PM

First they lie !!! But really do you have to stand in the flooded river, or hold on the a street sign to keep from blowing away JUST to tell people a storm is happening. !!
Just watching the hurricane reports and seems like they may be disappointed that the poor people in NC are not getting blown or washed away. Finally one reporter just ask "why am I so dry but the radar shows torrential rains". DON"T get me wrong this is one time I HOPE they are wrong.
Posted By: SNIPERBBB

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 02:00 PM

It looks cool. That's about it.
Posted By: odiferous

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 02:01 PM

Ratings. The worse they make it sound, the more people tune in. It's the same way with the news. It is ridiculous, isn't it? I hope they're wrong too.
Posted By: Hydropillar

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 02:06 PM

I agree the news thinks they have to oversentionalize everything!! this one the Storm of a lifetime. its a cat 4 and going to get stronger!! why couldnt they report it could weaken as it neared the coast. Im sure still a big storm for the people that live there but i dont see the heavy red in the hurricane only yellow and green hope that means not as much rain as they predicted..
anyway stay safe all down there!
They cry wolf so many times no one listens .
Fact of the matter is they cant predict the weather no matter how hard they try.
Me and the kids still laugh a few years back our first snowstorm of the year Shawn cable local meteoroligist reporting was standing on the side walk making a big deal out of it said pan down here by my feet !! showed a few flakes and said look how its building up on the sidewalk... it was melting about as fast as it was comeing down. good grief november in s dakota i predict it might snow!
Posted By: Muskrat

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 02:10 PM

I get a big laugh when they're out there "braving" the storm and there are a few surfing in the background.
Posted By: lumberjack391

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 02:39 PM

Not long ago I heard one say 'chance of rain today and a possibility of showers overnight" (This word is unacceptable on Trapperman)? I GUESS YOU COULD SAY THAT EVERYDAY AND BE RIGHT.....
Posted By: odiferous

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 03:48 PM

Another thing that gets me, is every time there's a couple inches of snow expected here, we're under a "winter weather advisory". At one time that meant we were going to get hammered. Now is seems our average daily winter weather is a life threatening ordeal.
Posted By: hippie

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 04:09 PM

I'm glad they do.

Easy to say idiots now that we've all seen what a hurricane, and being in one looks like (thanks to them) but before they ever did this, 95% of us would have no idea what they are talking about.

Without this, all we would know is some woman in high-heals in a studio saying the wind is blowing and it's raining down there.
Posted By: QuietButDeadly

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 04:36 PM

I agree that they tend to be idiots and try to over blow everything sometimes but I am also glad they are there for the good info that they do provide.

I have lived long enough to know that it was not always the way it is now and that was not necessarily a good thing either.

I was in elementary school in 1954 when Hurricane Hazel made landfall on the NC coast as what we call a Cat 4 now. It was a fast moving storm, moving around 30 miles per hour and the track brought the track just a few miles from my location, 180 miles from where it made landfall. We went to school the day it slammed the coast and by the time they put us on the bus to go home, it was raining sideways and the wind howling like I had never seen.

We did not get a mile before a big oak tree was blocking the road. Somehow, the bus driver managed to turn the bus around on that dirt road and got back to the main highway. She managed to get to my house on a paved road and to my Dad's country store with a bus load of kids. Several of the local farmers were at the store and they made sure that all of the kids got home that afternoon. Not sure what the wind speed was when they sent us home but we had hurricane force winds as the storm passed and lots of trees down. I am not sure the bus driver could have maneuvered through all of the down trees to get the kids home because some of the farmers had to use their chainsaws to get through with their trucks to get them home.

Point being, with all of the technology and communication we have now, that situation would not happen.
Posted By: Muskrat

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 05:02 PM

Good points QBD.

Before snow days . . . anyone else recall the school bus driver having to back up and ram snow drifts a couple of times to get on down the road? Now that was fun!
Posted By: SNIPERBBB

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 05:44 PM

Posted By: Law Dog

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 06:04 PM

Yet the weather guy acts like he barely make headway into the wind and a guy in the background is walking by no problem!
Posted By: AntiGov

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 06:04 PM

The drama is so faked , it becomes comical
Posted By: Newt

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 06:12 PM

You guy dont live on the coast. Ever see a storm surge ?
I have.The last time was SANDY
Lost alot. But would have lost more if I had'nt lifted things up. TWICE ! put things up ever higher as the tide came in.
Posted By: amspoker

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 07:44 PM

If they underestimated it, and no one prepared, we would blame them for not warning us.

Human nature at work.
Posted By: BigBob

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 09:20 PM

Emmy's
Posted By: Sullivan K

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 09:42 PM

Originally Posted By: jbyrd63
First they lie !!!


So, what is the lie?
Posted By: SNIPERBBB

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 10:02 PM

Now as far as the forecasts. Its better to say they are inaccurate. Everything is based off models, some of the better guys like Joe Bastardi at WeatherBell, use models combined with historical evidence and experience can make pretty good predictions but anything 72 or more hours out is always subject to change.

Models can only take what they know and then run the data through the programming that has to take into account some assumptions. Conditions change, local geographic effects arent taken into account etc. If you watch all the model runs, things can get pretty screwey, some show Florence coming back around again after it makes it back to the ocean.

Quote:
Excerpt from Aliens Cause Global Warming a lecture by Dr. Michael Crichton
To an outsider, the most significant innovation in
the global warming controversy is the overt
reliance that is being placed on models. Back in the days of nuclear winter, computer models
were invoked to add weight to a conclusion: “These results are derive
d with the help of a computer model.” But now, large-scale computer models are seen as generating data in
themselves. No longer are models judged by how
well they reproduce data from the real world—
increasingly, models provide the data. As if they
were themselves a reality. And indeed they are,
when we are projecting forward. There can be no observational data about
the year 2100. There are only model runs.

This fascination with computer models is something I understa
nd very well. Richard Feynmann called it a disease. I fear he is right. Because
only if you spend a lot of time looking at a
computer screen can you arrive at the comp
lex point where the global warming debate now
stands.

Nobody believes a weather prediction twelve hours ahead. Now we’re asked to believe a
prediction that goes out 100 years into the future? And make
financial investments based on that
prediction? Has everybody lost their minds?
Stepping back, I have to say the
arrogance of the model-makers is
breathtaking. There have been,
in every century, scientists who say they know it all. Sin
ce climate may be a chaotic system—no one is sure—these predictions are
inherently doubtful, to be polite.
But more to the point, even if
the models get the science spot-on, they can ne
ver get the sociology. To predict anything about
the world a hundred years from now is simply absurd.
Posted By: la4wd54

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/14/18 11:12 PM

And then there's this
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10158220173071980&id=542096979
Posted By: bblwi

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/15/18 04:01 AM

Most of those standing out in the weather for the cameras are not the weather persons they are the reporters. The real weather persons are in the the weather stations and rooms reviewing the radars etc. to give more accurate and timely info to the reporters and the public.

Bryce
Posted By: andrews1958

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/15/18 05:14 AM

I thought I was the only one that felt this way.

Seems like every storm is going to be the storm of the century and will hit land as a category 5 . 10 to 15 foot surges. Thousands of people leaving their homes do to mandatory evacuations or because they are scared due to all of the news hype.

With all the sophisticated satellites, weather planes, and storm situation rooms that can still not predict better

Is all about TV ratings and sensationalism?

If they keep calling wolf some day a real storm is going to hit and people are not going to believe them

Wish I could find it on You Tube but there was one clip where a reporter being rowed in a boats but when he passes another reporter he is in water below his knees
Posted By: snowy

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/15/18 12:00 PM

^ exactly.
Posted By: w side rd 151

Re: Weather men are idiots. - 09/15/18 12:48 PM

Yes the over hype gets old real quick. But the ratings mean the company that owns the channel need to have people watching .How many have ever heard of the Great Armistice Day Blizzard of 1940 ? A major blizzard hit the upper mid west that day and over 50 duck hunters died in the marshes that day while duck hunting .They had no way of knowing what was coming and it cost them their lives . Research it there are some amazing stories about some that survived and others that did not.
© 2024 Trapperman Forums