Home

Mental hospitals/ mass shootings?

Posted By: foxkidd44

Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 11:22 AM

Guys, just something I was thinking about,, but can’t seem to find any information to support my theory. Does anyone know when the mass closures of mental institutions began?? Mid 90s?? Seems that’s when the spike began. Yes,,, we’ve always had shootings to some degree,, but before the mid 90s they were isolated and not as common as they are now.
Posted By: Flicker Shad

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 11:30 AM

Yeah. We didn't have internet back then either. Think about that.
Posted By: Pawnee

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 11:32 AM

I don’t know the answer but I’ve heard that in the 1800’s up through the mid 1900’s we had something like 1000 mental hospital beds per 100,000 people. Now it’s less than 100 per 100,000. That’s from memory so don’t quote me. Now days they give them some pills and send them down the road. No oversight to see if the pills ever get taken.
Posted By: corky

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 11:59 AM

Jimmy Carter, followed up by Ronald Reagan, with the help of the Democrat majorities in Congress, passed the mental health legislation in the early 80"s. There have been a mountain of unintended consequences since then.
Posted By: Leftlane

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 12:03 PM

Has anybody heard anything about the little idiots father? I haven't been watching the news so maybe he was in the boys life maybe not.

It would seem to me that if his momma was a druggy then dad was probably too. I don't know if trying to identify and lock up the crazies would work but I cannot help but wonder that if children were raised in 2 parent homes if some of these kids would not be getting into nonsense like this
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 12:06 PM

We slapped mask on them and told them they were going to kill grandma....no wonder the youth have gone mad.
Posted By: w side rd 151

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 12:06 PM

The system today is built around the concept of medicating the symptoms . Mental illness is a disease just like many other medical problem .Today's medical profession(business) is not designed to treat the masses and follow up that treatment .It is all about making sure the medical professionals and institutions are getting their share of the profit .And the well being of the patient is secondary to the well being of the profit margin . Anyone that is having mental health issues is already having problems with understanding what to do .And giving that kind of person drugs that can make the situation worse. Throwing money at a problem is not the answer to changing the well being of someone that has the problem to begin with
Posted By: danny clifton

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 12:13 PM

Ronny Raygun emptied the mental institutions of CA when he was governor then cut funding to all the states as president.
Posted By: Brian Mongeau

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 01:11 PM

Originally Posted by foxkidd44
Guys, just something I was thinking about,, but can’t seem to find any information to support my theory. Does anyone know when the mass closures of mental institutions began?? Mid 90s?? Seems that’s when the spike began. Yes,,, we’ve always had shootings to some degree,, but before the mid 90s they were isolated and not as common as they are now.


CT State Hospital for the Insane opened in 1904, closed in 1996.
Posted By: GREENCOUNTYPETE

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 02:00 PM

Originally Posted by foxkidd44
Guys, just something I was thinking about,, but can’t seem to find any information to support my theory. Does anyone know when the mass closures of mental institutions began?? Mid 90s?? Seems that’s when the spike began. Yes,,, we’ve always had shootings to some degree,, but before the mid 90s they were isolated and not as common as they are now.


I think your talking about the Regan policy to de-fund and close mental hospitals that had in many cases life long residents.

as most things it started in California Reagan signed the first bill in 1967 slowly closing down long term care facilities

it was the mid 80s it went national a friend was a Deputy sheriff back then and they started to see in influx of mental folks visiting the jail.

as in most things it was a slow process so it took years.

mass killings have mostly followed population , there were 61 active shooter events in 2021, 12 of which qualify as a mass killing event 103 dead 140 injured that was a steep increase from the previous year 40 and prior to 2020-2021 30 had been the common median number.

what changed , I think it has a lot to do with the way the media sells it , if you watch the news you might have seen numbers like 693 mass shootings , clearly they are getting their statistics from other places , no surprise they are including every possible criminal shooting to make up their numbers things that have known motive and intended victims often where few are innocent in the exchange

when you sell every day that it is common and polarize absolutely everything push every stresser people snap so they take advantage of weak people prone to snapping and help push it in a more violent direction.


Posted By: KeithC

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 02:56 PM

I put the blame mostly on the media too. They put the idea of going on a shooting spree in people's heads with their beyond extensive coverage of a shooting spree when it happens. The media then brings up that shooting every year on it's "anniversary" and every time another somewhat similar shooting occurs, ad nauseum.

Keith
Posted By: hippie

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 03:22 PM

It's what we as a society have allowed to be normalized. What is a mental case anymore?

Would you consider this person mentally stable or hire him for a very important position in the federal govy?
[Linked Image]

Or maybe this person for another important position?
[Linked Image]

If those are not crazy but revered enough to run agencies within our govt, this one is probably ok too?
[Linked Image]
(in charge of nuclear waste)


Yes, we're talking about mental health all the while normalizing it at a federal level. Go figure.
Posted By: Oh Snap

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 03:34 PM

All 3 of these sick human beings were recruited, in the shadows, by a pervert at a young age….just like they are doing right now IN PLAIN SIGHT!

Originally Posted by hippie
It's what we as a society have allowed to be normalized. What is a mental case anymore?

Would you consider this person mentally stable or hire him for a very important position in the federal govy?
[Linked Image]

Or maybe this person for another important position?
[Linked Image]

If those are not crazy but revered enough to run agencies within our govt, this one is probably ok too?
[Linked Image]
(in charge of nuclear waste)


Yes, we're talking about mental health all the while normalizing it at a federal level. Go figure.

Posted By: KeithC

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 03:48 PM

Aberrant behavior is a requirement to be a part of the biden administration.

Keith
Posted By: w side rd 151

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 03:57 PM

In today's society everyone wants to express their individuality But no one wants to accept responsibility for their actions .Than when things go bad it has to be someone elses fault because it is unfair to single out those that are different There are many people that need help and want help but the system fails them by putting into programs that only put a band aid on a critical problem And when those people do something tragic everyone points the finger and says that is the problem
Posted By: Mike in A-town

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 04:39 PM

There was a lot of abuse in the mental institutions back in the day... The stories of experiments on the patients isn't just Hollywood horror movie stuff.

But instead of trying to fix that, we threw the baby out with the bathwater and shut the hospitals down.

I am generally opposed to government handling things... But after one mass shooting, don't remember which... Parkland maybe, and the issue of mental illness came up... Ben Shapiro made a pretty good point... The burden of the mentally ill falls on society as a whole. So it should be up to society to fund and undertake the care of the mentally ill.

We need to decide what criteria must be met for a person to be deemed dangerous enough to be institutionalized and apply those criteria. I have to wonder how many parents/family had an inkling that these kids need to be locked up and just ignored it or hoped the worst wouldn't happen... Or worse yet, looked into having something done and found out it was nearly impossible. Because getting someone committed long-term is nearly impossible. They basically have to commit a criminal act before the state will even consider it.

But everything is politicized now... And I'm not sure government could be trusted to set the standards for what qualifies as crazy now. All of the proposed red flag law legislation makes that apparent... Democrats want to lock you up for simply wanting to own a firearm.

Mike
Posted By: Boco

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 05:09 PM

i bet there was a lot more shootings in the 1700's and 1800's per capita than today.
Posted By: w side rd 151

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 05:16 PM

Originally Posted by Mike in A-town
There was a lot of abuse in the mental institutions back in the day... The stories of experiments on the patients isn't just Hollywood horror movie stuff.

But instead of trying to fix that, we threw the baby out with the bathwater and shut the hospitals down.

I am generally opposed to government handling things... But after one mass shooting, don't remember which... Parkland maybe, and the issue of mental illness came up... Ben Shapiro made a pretty good point... The burden of the mentally ill falls on society as a whole. So it should be up to society to fund and undertake the care of the mentally ill.

We need to decide what criteria must be met for a person to be deemed dangerous enough to be institutionalized and apply those criteria. I have to wonder how many parents/family had an inkling that these kids need to be locked up and just ignored it or hoped the worst wouldn't happen... Or worse yet, looked into having something done and found out it was nearly impossible. Because getting someone committed long-term is nearly impossible. They basically have to commit a criminal act before the state will even consider it.

But everything is politicized now... And I'm not sure government could be trusted to set the standards for what qualifies as crazy now. All of the proposed red flag law legislation makes that apparent... Democrats want to lock you up for simply wanting to own a firearm.

Mike
We need to decide what criteria must be met for a person to be deemed danger but everything is so politicized now Democrats want to lock you up for wanting to own a gun. Now a days if you have any opinion other than guns are dangerous you are considered a criminal
Posted By: Blaine County

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 05:40 PM

Since the McDonalds shooting in 1984 (21 dead people) we have added over a 100 million people in the U.S. And, social media. If one percent of the population are nuts, we added an additional one million additional nuts to the general population (on top of the nuts already there). I expect social media and general societal decline increases the percentage of nuts.

The Constitution does not have an adjustment for population growth--nor should it. In fact, we more of a reason to protect ourselves now as the country gets crazier and more crowded.
Posted By: WANNABE-TRAPPER

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 09:08 PM

Originally Posted by danny clifton
Ronny Raygun emptied the mental institutions of CA when he was governor then cut funding to all the states as president.


Yep

Huge portion of this is because our healthcare system sucks if you are poor. Zero help.
Posted By: Ole

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 09:25 PM

There was to be promise of government funding for state and local mental health programs to make up for the closures. Guess what?
Posted By: 330-Trapper

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/30/22 11:15 PM

Originally Posted by KeithC
I put the blame mostly on the media too. They put the idea of going on a shooting spree in people's heads with their beyond extensive coverage of a shooting spree when it happens. The media then brings up that shooting every year on it's "anniversary" and every time another somewhat similar shooting occurs, ad nauseum.

Keith

This I believe
Posted By: ky_coyote_hunter

Re: Mental hospitals/ mass shootings? - 05/31/22 12:21 AM

Originally Posted by KeithC
I put the blame mostly on the media too. They put the idea of going on a shooting spree in people's heads with their beyond extensive coverage of a shooting spree when it happens. The media then brings up that shooting every year on it's "anniversary" and every time another somewhat similar shooting occurs, ad nauseum.

Keith

Yep, the media is complicit.
© 2024 Trapperman Forums