Which is Older?

Both of them are swolled up in the neck and have puny racks, poor in structure. I'd drop them both in hopes that a better quality buck could spread his genes instead of these two delicious losers.

I have a buck on our place that could be a twin of that second one.

I am no expert but the top one looks older?

That’s not what I asked so you get an F for not following directions. lol

Impossible to tell looking at the butt pic

Pure gold. This is where my brother used to shoot deer.

I have to agree with jbyrd, without a broadside pic it is just a WAG

What I can tell you is the 2nd is old enough he should have a better set of antlers.

I think the 2nd is 3 (back is still flat, no sway), 1st is probably at least the same.

Disclaimer: I am a novice at aging deer

Need a broadside picture to check back sway, belly and brisket depth in particular.

Hard to tell

The second picture was taken a day sooner, therfore it must be older.

Hobbie is gonna give you an F for sure now

I’m pretty sure it’s the same deer in both pictures;-)

I don't think its the same deer but hard to compare deer build with the one walking away. Just a quick glance would say there are close to the same age.

That's funny. Delicious losers. Lol

Clearly the second one is older by 8 hours 51 min. You'd think more trappers would see the sign.

We're not as smart as you. LOL.

Yeah, that’s an F.

Kill both, pull the lower jaw out and get them aged.

Jbyrd and Bear tracker have the best answer. Need better pictures.

I know of NO ONE that can age a deer from a rear end pic. Based on what’s given I’ll say the second deer and if you need to fill a tag, take him regardless of age.

Here's the video but he still isn't really broad side like the other.

Nope! I think 8 hours and 20 minutes!

not sure which is older, but they are not the same deer.

I can accept that grade. I figured if anyone could appreciate my wry sense of humor, it would be you.

I am guessing the top deer. Seems wide in the stern.

ya done let both of em get old and tough

The Outdoor life " OK shot "

Did it once with an 2116 Arrow . Fastest kill ever bowhunting

Top one older