Home

What is the best cherry tree?

Posted By: 2zwudz

What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 01:34 AM

What is the best cherry tree for making cherry pies?
Posted By: yotetrapper30

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 02:15 AM

Montmorency!
Posted By: KeithC

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 02:47 AM

Originally Posted by yotetrapper30
Montmorency!


For pies, Montmorency is it. They spread well by root and grow close to a clone from seed too.I have around 140 yards of Montmorency cherry trees along my ditch line. Three year old trees will bare fruit, if attached to the mother tree's root system. Few pests bother them. I get fruit every year. I probably have well over 400 Montmorency cherry trees on my farm, counting small ones.

[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]

If you get some sour cherry trees, get the pitter/stoner I pictured. It will pit cherries very quickly and save a lot of otherwise hard work. Enterprise is one of the main makers. They are about $140.00 new, but you can buy antique pitters for under $10.00 at auction. We have 3 pitters, so when we have people over to pick, we can make short work of the cherries.


Keith
Posted By: beaverpeeler

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 04:00 AM

One you planted 10 years ago.
Posted By: waggler

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 05:15 AM

There are some cherry trees in southeast Alaska, particularly around Haines that look like pie cherries, red and translucent, but they are sweet. Anyone know what they are called?
Posted By: upstateNY

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 07:09 AM

Originally Posted by KeithC
Originally Posted by yotetrapper30
Montmorency!


For pies, Montmorency is it. They spread well by root and grow close to a clone from seed too.I have around 140 yards of Montmorency cherry trees along my ditch line. Three year old trees will bare fruit, if attached to the mother tree's root system. Few pests bother them. I get fruit every year. I probably have well over 400 Montmorency cherry trees on my farm, counting small ones.

[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]

If you get some sour cherry trees, get the pitter/stoner I pictured. It will pit cherries very quickly and save a lot of otherwise hard work. Enterprise is one of the main makers. They are about $140.00 new, but you can buy antique pitters for under $10.00 at auction. We have 3 pitters, so when we have people over to pick, we can make short work of the cherries.


Keith

Cant seem to find that pitter new,,,only used ones on EBay?
Posted By: Bruce T

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 10:44 AM

Royal Duke
Posted By: wytex

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 08:24 PM

Montmorency cherries make nice cherry bounce too, with honey not sugar.
Posted By: BigBlackBirds

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 08:49 PM

I do like montmorency but if I was planting it’d be balatons
Posted By: KeithC

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 10:02 PM

Originally Posted by waggler
There are some cherry trees in southeast Alaska, particularly around Haines that look like pie cherries, red and translucent, but they are sweet. Anyone know what they are called?


Those are likely Nanking cherries they are sweeter than sour cherries. Most Nanking cherries are red. The white Nanking cherries are even sweeter.

Keith
Posted By: KeithC

Re: What is the best cherry tree? - 05/05/25 10:07 PM

Originally Posted by upstateNY
Cant seem to find that pitter new,,,only used ones on EBay?


Lehmans sells the pitters new.

https://www.lehmans.com/product/old-fashioned-cherry-pitter

Many estate auctions have them.

Shopgoodwill usally has some for sale. Here's one.

https://shopgoodwill.com/item/229310865

Keith

© 2025 Trapperman Forums