Home

What's on your pizza?

Posted By: Nittany Lion

What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:35 PM

I like lots of toppings, pepperoni, bacon, sausage, mushrooms, salami, onions, mozzarella cheese, grated parmesan chees and green peppers.
Posted By: HobbieTrapper

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:40 PM

Everything except pineapple.
Posted By: tomahawker

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:44 PM

Every ting, even a lil anchovie
Posted By: ~ADC~

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:45 PM

Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, and lots of mozzarella cheese on top of the toppings except like to put the pepperoni on top of the cheese so it gets crisped up some, thin crispy crust. We're making home made pizza for supper tonight. My wife is having Canadian bacon and Bavarian sauerkraut on hers. I'll have a slice of it too. I like green peppers but they over-power the other flavors on a pizza to me so I leave them off, same for black olives, love them, just not on pizza.
Posted By: hippie

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:45 PM

Pepperoni is good enough for me if it comes from OIP.

Store bought ones I like the Supremes that have all that stuff.
Posted By: GREENCOUNTYPETE

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:47 PM

eveything but the crust
Posted By: maintenanceguy

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:53 PM

mushrooms and extra cheese.

But my favorite that I haven't had in more than 20 years:

I lived in the NYC area for about 10 years after high school. "macaroni" pizza is thing up there that I haven't found here. It's pizza with a very thick layer of penne or rigatoni pasta in a meat sauce with lots of melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese. It's basically a 1" thick layer of baked ziti on a pizza crust. One slice is a meal. Delicious.
Posted By: Aix sponsa

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:55 PM

Ham and pineapple, supreme, deep dish, thin crust, loaded with toppings, cheese only, it really doesn’t matter, I like it all. I haven’t had anchovies though. I may or may not like that.


Pickled banana pepper rings or pepperoncini peppers are needed after cooking.
Posted By: arcticotter

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 06:57 PM

MEAT!
Posted By: Nittany Lion

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:18 PM

Hippie, do you ever make your own pizza?
Posted By: Strut10

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:20 PM

Haha !!!!

Surfing and eating pizza right now.

Double cheese, pepperoni, sweet Italian sausage, shrooms and onions

I can suffer most any toppings EXCEPT pineapple and black olives. sick
Posted By: Bruce T

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:21 PM

Originally Posted by Nittany Lion
I like lots of toppings, pepperoni, bacon, sausage, mushrooms, salami, onions, mozzarella cheese, grated parmesan chees and green peppers.

X2
Posted By: Willy Firewood

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:23 PM

This is funny!

Ok - regular crust, extra sauce, double mushrooms, green peppers, and a regular quantity of mozzarella cheese - no extra.
Wife and I have strongly agreed on this exact same way for 40some years.
Posted By: the Blak Spot

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:36 PM

Black olives, pineapple, onions, and bacon
Posted By: nvwrangler

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:38 PM

Preferred choice thin crispy crust , lite sauce, all meat, add onions and extra cheese well done. wood fired pickled jalapenos on the side

I will eat a combo at times and pineapple I can take or leave. There is a place here that does have a good deep dish that we order once in a while.

One of my favorites is thin crust, lite sauce, double pepperoni with extra cheese. Then add slices of fresh tomato , dash of tabasco and parmesan cheese as you eat it.
Posted By: Slick Pan

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:40 PM

it would depend on the crust and the quality of the ingredients
Posted By: DWC

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:43 PM

Ever been to Pizza Rev? Its like a subway for pizza because u just point at anything you want and then into the giant oven it goes. Pretty good stuff id recommend it.
Posted By: Mike in A-town

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 07:51 PM

Cheese, mushrooms, bacon, and Canadian bacon.

Mike
Posted By: hippie

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 08:01 PM

Originally Posted by Nittany Lion
Hippie, do you ever make your own pizza?


Nope, unless you consider those kits the school kids sell as making my own.

OIP is the best I've ever ate followed by marcello's or whatever their name is that's up here by the 4 lane. OIP hoagies can't be beat either, love the bread they make.
Posted By: Nessmuck

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 08:02 PM

A good slice of tomato... spinache...and feta..hits the spot. Most time just plain cheese
Posted By: ~ADC~

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 08:03 PM

You realize some of you don't have meat on your pizza? What do you do, use it as a side dish for your steak?
Posted By: Whopper Stopper

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 08:05 PM

pepperoni, cheese and gobs of sauerkraut


WS
Posted By: Aix sponsa

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 08:08 PM

Originally Posted by ~ADC~
You realize some of you don't have meat on your pizza? What do you do, use it as a side dish for your steak?





Steak and pizza sounds good actually.
Posted By: GREENCOUNTYPETE

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 08:14 PM

the kids love pizza , this has probably been laminated to the inside of the cupboard door for 12 year since

ignore step 3 , it goes right onto an oiled cast iron pizza pan and spread out , let rest a bit then pressed out and baked 10 minutes then topped and cooked 10 more

my oldest started making this about age 10 that is why my wife laminated it to the inside of the cupboard door thick , thin , deep dish , you can make it any way you like based on how you spread it or the pan you put it in , thick or deep dish bake longer

used to be almost every Friday night

I can't do the crust any more (carbs) but they still make it some

[Linked Image]
Posted By: Sharon

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 08:50 PM

Most all the toppings mentioned above. Except that greasy pepperoni. UHG..... just chunks of beef or Italian sausage , Canadian bacon, onion, black olive, shrooms, green peppah , even pineapple....lots of sauce .

And there is nevah enough tomato sauce for me !
Posted By: Trapper Dahlgren

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:01 PM

meat lovers well done
Posted By: Bigbrownie

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:02 PM

Pepperoni, sausage and green peppers.
Posted By: trapperEd

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:07 PM


I make my own, Pillsbury Thin Crust.
1 Jar of Raos Home Made Pizza Sauce
1 Small can of Mushrooms
Then covered with "Thick Cut Pepperoni
One half pound Mozzarella Cheese

Yummy
Sometimes I use Italian Sausage instead of the Pepperoni and add Banana Peppers.
Posted By: fishnhunts

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:32 PM

Originally Posted by maintenanceguy
mushrooms and extra cheese.



This is my favorite. I'll take pepperoni's too, but I'm good with this pizza.
Posted By: Brian Mongeau

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:34 PM

All the meats.
Onion, jalapeno, pineapple.
Hold the green peppers, mushrooms, olives and fish
Posted By: HayDay

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:43 PM

Whatever the guy or gal in the kitchen at Casey's put on it.
Posted By: vermontster

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:47 PM

Chili hotdogs and onions and cheese
Posted By: bwtrapper

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 09:52 PM

Thin crust, sausage, cheese, mushrooms and onions.
Posted By: yotetrapper30

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:05 PM

My favorite is original crust, double cheese, and just pepperoni. I like pepperoni and sausage okay too. Definitely NO veggies of any sort. I'll eat it with pretty much any meats though.

I always thought pineapple on pizza was nasty, but I tried it and it's not bad. Not my first choice, but I'll eat it if the meat is ham or canadian bacon... any other meats with pineapple would be weird, lol.

I also like chicken pizzas.... buffalo chicken, BBQ chicken, chicken alfredo, etc.
Posted By: beartooth trapr

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:16 PM

Anything meat lovers, but stuff crust is good also
Posted By: jeff karsten

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:20 PM

Ham and Pineapple thin crust sometimes i get wild and add pepperoni
Posted By: mike mason

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:28 PM

Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatball, salami and extra cheese.
Posted By: Old pup

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:29 PM

Everything except pineapple and tomatoes. Heavy on the anchovies. Lots of Tabasco sauce, too.
Posted By: Flicker Shad

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:42 PM

Originally Posted by HobbieTrapper
Everything except pineapple.

Pineapple is good when Canadian bacon and jalapeños are added.
Posted By: charles

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:47 PM

We stick with these four items. Pepperoni, Italian sausage, Black Olives, and Nushrooms
Posted By: Rat_Pack

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 10:59 PM

NY style with sausage, peppers, onions and mushrooms
Posted By: Lugnut

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 11:02 PM

Extra cheese and lots of mushrooms.
Posted By: Snyde901

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 11:48 PM

Originally Posted by Aix sponsa
Originally Posted by ~ADC~
You realize some of you don't have meat on your pizza? What do you do, use it as a side dish for your steak?





Steak and pizza sounds good actually.



There's a local place here that makes the best steak pizza. It has a white alfredo type sauce instead of tomato then they pile on the chipped steak, cheese, onions, & peppers.
Posted By: CoonsBane

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 11:54 PM

Mushrooms and anchovies.
Posted By: Aix sponsa

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/18/22 11:57 PM

‘Possum and Sweet Pataters
Posted By: coyote 1

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 12:01 AM

Thin crust. Beef, bacon, peppers and mushroom. Sometimes onion.
Posted By: rick olson

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 12:08 AM

Sausage,mushroom and smoked Gouda with a few red grapes.
Posted By: Mike in A-town

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 01:00 AM

I don't dislike pepperoni but it sure doesn't like me... I prefer to taste my food just once. I don't get that option with pepperoni.

Mike
Posted By: bucksnbears

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 01:22 AM

Usually lots of meat and a big bell pepper on top.
Has to be a bit well done for me. Not so much the crust but the toppings.
Posted By: midlander

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 01:32 AM

Chicken bacon ranch pizza with a touch of onion....ranch sauce instead of mater based. Gadzukes, it is good!
Posted By: Brian Mongeau

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 01:32 AM

Originally Posted by yotetrapper30
My favorite is original crust, double cheese, and just pepperoni. I like pepperoni and sausage okay too. Definitely NO veggies of any sort. I'll eat it with pretty much any meats though.

I always thought pineapple on pizza was nasty, but I tried it and it's not bad. Not my first choice, but I'll eat it if the meat is ham or canadian bacon... any other meats with pineapple would be weird, lol.

I also like chicken pizzas.... buffalo chicken, BBQ chicken, chicken alfredo, etc.


Chicken and pineapple...May be weird, but it's good.
Posted By: DelawareRob

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 01:50 AM

Originally Posted by tomahawker
Every ting, even a lil anchovie


X2
Posted By: DelawareRob

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 01:54 AM

Originally Posted by Flicker Shad
Originally Posted by HobbieTrapper
Everything except pineapple.

Pineapple is good when Canadian bacon and jalapeños are added.


Oh yeah!

We have what we call a border to border sometimes.

Canadian bacon and jalapeños!

Would be really cool to do a true all borders.

Pineapple, jalapeño, Canadian bacon, and something from the east coast I guess. Just don’t know what?
Posted By: AntiGov

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 02:01 AM

Hard to beat a straight up pepperoni pizza

But when I kick it up a notch , it's pepperoni , sausage , fresh mushrooms , fresh jalapenos , extra cheese , and lots of black pepper
Posted By: AntiGov

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 02:02 AM

And pineapple ...... NEVER !!!!
Posted By: Aix sponsa

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 02:03 AM

Delaware Rob, the east coast topping would need to be something like clams, lobster, or eel. My opinion. That’d be a great border to border
Posted By: DelawareRob

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 02:13 AM

Originally Posted by Aix sponsa
Delaware Rob, the east coast topping would need to be something like clams, lobster, or eel. My opinion. That’d be a great border to border


Yeah! Clams or lobster. Or my personal favorite blue claw crabs!

Perhaps!!

Maybe Sika deer or something.


Maybe make is an all seafood pizza.

Something from each region.

Yum.

We have a local place that makes a fisherman’s pizza. It is fantastic.

You may be on to a great idea.
Posted By: Aix sponsa

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 02:41 AM

Blue crabs would be awesome and represent them well. I prefer lump over claw meat, but I’ll gladly take both.


So 4 coast pizza would be jalapeño, Canadian bacon, blue crabs, and pineapple plus cheese and sauce, of course. Just to be clear, because I think we’re talking about a new style...?


I’d order it. You?
Posted By: DelawareRob

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 02:43 AM

Originally Posted by Aix sponsa
Blue crabs would be awesome and represent them well. I prefer lump over claw meat, but I’ll gladly take both.


So 4 coast pizza would be jalapeño, Canadian bacon, blue crabs, and pineapple plus cheese and sauce, of course. Just to be clear, because I think we’re talking about a new style...?


I’d order it. You?


Heck yeah. I’d eat the heck out of that!
Posted By: ~ADC~

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 10:59 PM

Had a power outage last night so we didn't our pizzas built until today. Turned out exceptional...

[Linked Image]
Posted By: watt

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 11:19 PM

Anyone for hot peppers and black olives?
Posted By: Willy Firewood

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/19/22 11:50 PM

The NEVER list: pepperoni, hot peppers, jalapeño peppers, bacon, black or green olives or anchovies.

Real Canadian bacon, extra sauce, and extra pineapple with normal (no extra) cheese is very good.

I am curious about sauerkraut.
Posted By: T-Rex

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 12:24 AM

Shrimp and mushrooms on thin crust. That, under the sauce and cheese that I believe are a part of the definition of pizza.
Posted By: Drifter

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 12:49 AM

No peppers, pineapple or fish bait. Pile on most the rest
Posted By: GritGuy

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 01:47 AM

I won't touch a pizza if it has veggies on it, not a one.

Has to be deep dish and most meats, but at least pepperoni, sausage, and has to have pineapple !!
Posted By: Aix sponsa

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 01:57 AM

I usually agree with ole Willy, but I have to question the never list. Never Pepperoni? Hot peppers? No extra cheese?


Sound like questionable choices honestly.



LOL
Posted By: 330-Trapper

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 02:28 AM

Lotza motza, sausage and pepperoni
Posted By: MJM

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 02:57 AM

I never understood why people smear some tomato sauce on a cracker thin crust and slap a thin piece of cheese on it and call it pizza. Put some meat and cheese on it. [Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
Posted By: ack

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 09:43 AM

Meat with jalapeños added.
Those attending the NTA convention this year will have a chance to have the pizza we ate tonight. It is right across the road from the fairgrounds. Beer barrel pizza. Really good and awesome wings.
Posted By: Alex the dog

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 12:49 PM

Bought crust with homemade white sauce, partially sautéed fresh morels, bacon and pepperoni or pork sausage topped with shredded Asiago cheese is my favorite
Dave

[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
Posted By: Snyde901

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 01:13 PM

Originally Posted by Alex the dog
Bought crust with homemade white sauce, partially sautéed fresh morels, bacon and pepperoni or pork sausage topped with shredded Asiago cheese is my favorite
Dave

[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]

You win, that looks delicious. Do you deliver? grin
Posted By: imissed

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 01:14 PM

Doesn't matter what topping except NO GREEN PEPPERS!!!

1 little piece of pepper will ruin a pizza. The whole thing will taste like peppers.
Posted By: Posco

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 01:26 PM

Macaroni and cheese pizza. Seriously. They make it at a local deli and it's delicious.
Posted By: Wright Brothers

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 01:31 PM

Blind robins. grin
Posted By: waggler

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 03:58 PM

Anything but pineapple. I wonder who it was who thought pineapple was a good idea on pizza.
Posted By: Cragar

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 05:15 PM

Originally Posted by waggler
I wonder who it was who thought pineapple was a good idea on pizza.


A greek-Canadian immigrant invented it in Ontario.

So it is not Hawaiian at all.
Posted By: Coyote Clayton

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 05:34 PM

Thin crust sauerkraut, Canadian bacon, double cheese.
Posted By: Alex the dog

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 05:59 PM

Originally Posted by Snyde901
Originally Posted by Alex the dog
Bought crust with homemade white sauce, partially sautéed fresh morels, bacon and pepperoni or pork sausage topped with shredded Asiago cheese is my favorite
Dave

[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]

You win, that looks delicious. Do you deliver? grin


I’ve never been to PA but would like to so we could probably work something out
grin
Posted By: mad_mike

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 07:40 PM

Sweet hot Italian sausage, burger, cheese, onion, and mushrooms. Chicken and bacon with spinach is pretty good too.

Originally Posted by Coyote Clayton
Thin crust sauerkraut, Canadian bacon, double cheese.


I have to try the sauerkraut now on pizza.
Posted By: Snyde901

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 10:23 PM


You win, that looks delicious. Do you deliver? grin[/quote]

I’ve never been to PA but would like to so we could probably work something out
grin[/quote]
That would go great with some freshly harvested deep fried wild turkey boneless "wings", think I'll have to give it a try this spring.
Posted By: greenetrapper

Re: What's on your pizza? - 02/20/22 10:46 PM

Jalapenos and bacon with extra sauce
© 2024 Trapperman Forums