Some critter has been leaving these little presents around my garage for years, mostly right around the garage doors for some reason.
Any ideas?

Looks like a Chicken turd

Yes, I was thinking maybe some kind of bird too, but no chickens around here what so ever.

I should also add... whatever the culprit is, it always does its job at night.

Some kind of small owl maybe??

Possum is my guess. I’ve seen the same type in front of my garage door also.

I have big toads that leave turds that big. See if its full of wings, legs and shells.

Are you saving the quarters it leaves behind also?

Down here we have these large lizards we call skinks, they leave turds like that. Don't know if you have them or not?

Toad !

Yes, toad.

Most likely Hillary Clinton..

Yes, have toads here in wi.
No, no turds in winter.
I guess it could be a toad. I have a bunch of field stone rock work off to one side of my garage where it could be living in I guess.
Must be a big old boy who craps big.

So what do you figure, dirt hole or flat set?? Lol.

Toad.

Toad, have them on my sidewalk every morning. I see him most evenings when I let the dog out.

You boys have some big toads. I’m gonna set up a trail cam to see this toad crap that thing.

I have a chipmunk that takes a dump a couple times a week by the front door of my camp. Looks similar to that.

Yup, a Toad.

I toad you so!

Most defiantly go with the flat set with a small amount of fly juice , try not to over do it .