Well, I see this thread is still bouncing around, so I'll add my two cents worth. I've always liked the woven baskets. When I upgrade to a new one, the old one becomes the basket for ice fishing gear.
It's been awhile since the Amish basket maker set up at the WTA rondy, but when he did, he had packbaskets setting out for sale among other handwoven baskets. One rondy maybe awhile back I asked him to make a basket to my specs, and he came back the next year with it done. I believe he charged me just over a hundred bucks. To me it was worth it. Exactly what I wanted.
That isn't a 5-gallon bucket, maybe 3-gallon. With a #11 on top of it. But you get a real nice shot of the leather straps, first rate.
I gave this basket three coats of spar varnish before using it. Guess what the basket is made of? Most Amish in this area make all their baskets out of this material.
It's made out of bamboo. Those of you who remember starting out with a cane pole, how long did that cane pole last you? Years, right? I wanted a basket that you could really fill up, strap on, and away you go.
Setting this basket in the otter sled and away you go for back bottom edge setting.
Today's baskets just seem too small. This basket is only as heavy as the gear/critters you put into it. Older pics. I've upgraded to all #150s and got rid of the #110s.
Anyway, this is what I like. Works for me.