Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: garymc]
#7265851
05/16/21 09:11 PM
05/16/21 09:11 PM
|
Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 11,294 Maine, Aroostook
Posco
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Nov 2017
Posts: 11,294
Maine, Aroostook
|
Danny, they are built with cast. Exactly. The proper cast allows for proper eye alignment with the barrel without getting to much check into the stock, which really helps with the quick and consistent mounting. Not to mention less hammering of the cheek. Not many Americans are familiar with cast. Cast on/cast off. An eighth to quarter inch of cast can make a big difference in gun fit.
|
|
|
Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: nvwrangler]
#7265907
05/16/21 11:03 PM
05/16/21 11:03 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2015
Posts: 3,077 Wyoming
cmcf
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Oct 2015
Posts: 3,077
Wyoming
|
Wow just browsed CDNN I guess the MSR & Tactical Joes have taken the place over They had some Dickenson O&U for 2900 but that was IT. They used to have dozens of sporting shotguns from Citories to 101 and Winchester field grade made in the Browning plant in Belgium. Oh well the times they are a changing.
“The world is governed by very different personages from what is imagined” B. Disraeli
|
|
|
Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: nvwrangler]
#7266143
05/17/21 11:32 AM
05/17/21 11:32 AM
|
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 715 Michigan
BigBlackBirds
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 715
Michigan
|
The biggest difference between the brands mentioned so far is in the stock dimensions, such as comb height. A shotgun HAS to fit the shooter, and the Italian guns have a higher comb that the Browning field guns.
I suggest shooting both and go from there. Over the years I saw a lot of customers who owned Citoris that caused facial abuse because their cheek was not firmly planted on the comb as it was too low. Also, a 26'' barrel with give you more perceived recoil that a 28''.
Just my thinking.
Pete The cc I looked at today did have an adjustable comb, wish I could get to shoot a couple different ones nvwrangler---All the entry level B guns that have been suggested in this thread are rock solid reliable guns. You can't go wrong with either berretta or browning plus plenty of others and that also means that buying used can be a good option. Most of these target style guns are made to fit the "average" shooter to begin with. There are some engineered differences between the american style fit and european fit but its no longer that hard to make most guns fit everyone. In this era, a good number of guns are adjustable right out of the box and after market combs are easy to pick up (may or may not be good investment depending on situation). You can adjust point of impact left/right, up/down just like a rifle. However, my advice would be to spend as much time looking and trying out guns as possible before you spend ANY money given that O/U's arent exactly inexpensive. My gun safe is a good reminder of the shotguns that thought i wanted or needed but that didn't really work for me. See what your friends have that you can handle and test. Maybe try a large club and see what others have; if you ask, most of us will let you try ours out. Given what can be done with fit, for me picking a shotgun is really about feel; what feels right makes them much more enjoyable to shoot but it also makes them work better for you. The gun has to fit you so that the eyes and barrel mesh BUT how the gun handles should also be of primary concern as wingshooting is all about getting the barrel where it needs to be and gun handling drives that. There are some quantitative features regarding handling such as total weight, length of barrels, or where exactly the gun balances but all of that becomes a bit subjective to the shooter given their shooting style and what targets they might be engaging. For field use i have an old browning 325 20 gauge and newer beretta 686 12gauge. Both are fitted with aftermarket combs and i can use both decently. however if i'm shooting competitively neither one of those guns handle all that great for me.
|
|
|
Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: Paul D. Heppner]
#7266243
05/17/21 02:18 PM
05/17/21 02:18 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 715 Michigan
BigBlackBirds
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 715
Michigan
|
SJA, looks interesting. Does one shoot from the pentagram in the center or is that the trap position and the shooter travels to the numbered squares? The two clays clubs I belong to have much larger layouts. Northstar Sportsmans Club, Hamlin, NY and Rochester Brooks, Rush, NY. NorthStar is pretty much a skeet in the woods course. there are about 30 traps on the club grounds with some on a 5 stand layout. I use the 20 with light skeet chokes and do well. These are 50 targets that must be broken to pad your score in a big shoot. About a half mile walk in the woods. Brooks on the other hand is an easy 1.5+ mile walk on 2 courses termed the sub gauge course (50 targets) and the tournament course (100 targets). Bring your 12 and be prepared to choke up at times on the tournament course. I usually put the light mod and improved mod in at the beginning and leave them in for the duration. Brooks has 125 or more traps plus a 5 stand layout with enclosed, and heated in the winter, shooting positions. Both courses have a combination of woods and field stations. 20, 28, and 410 were made for the sub gauge course, the 20 might be a little overkill. Brooks will almost always have 3 or more traps on a station and sometimes 2 shooting stands. They also have a HIGH tower over a gully. We never see single targets here, always reports or true pairs. Both clubs have web sights, check them out. I never saw a clay target that didn't deserve to be broken. Did you happen to shoot the registered event this past weekend at Rochester Brooks?
|
|
|
Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: nvwrangler]
#7266331
05/17/21 05:51 PM
05/17/21 05:51 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 165 Pennsylvania
Tim64
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 165
Pennsylvania
|
I owned several O/U shotguns in my life, but my two favorite were the Browning Citori Featherlight and the Franchi Falconet Buckskin. Both were 12 gauge. The Franchi weighed 5-lbs 7-ozs and the Browning weighed just over 6-lbs. Both were used for grouse hunting. I'm too old to hunt grouse now and passed my shotguns to my sons.
Last edited by Tim64; 05/17/21 05:52 PM.
|
|
|
Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: nvwrangler]
#7266377
05/17/21 07:06 PM
05/17/21 07:06 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 726 Hilton, NY
Paul D. Heppner
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 726
Hilton, NY
|
BigBlackBirds, no I didn't. I haven't shot it for a few years. I started reffing several years ago. I am an NSCA certified Sporting ref, so instead of paying $1.00 plus a target and getting to watch 4 or 5 other shooters in my squad that I may or may not learn anything from, I get paid $80.00 a day to watch about 200 shooters better than half of which I can learn something from. I take my pay in targets. It's a 3 day shoot and I haven't payed for any targets in a few years. Plus my competition days are behind me. My eyes and reflexes aren't what they used to be. I'm 70 years old and lugging an 8 to 9 pound gun, 6 boxes of shells, and my shooting bag just doesn't have the thrill that it used to. That course is a mile and a half give or take and I refuse to rent one of their golf carts. IMHO a golf cart is an unfair advantage and it's an obnoxious distraction to a shooter in the box that's trying to concentrate on his task at hand. If a shooter is disabled that's another story and the cart is justified. I'm not there quite yet. Besides, I'll be able to go on Wednesday and shoot the same targets off my card which at last check still held about 1300 or so targets. That shoot, the Spring Deuce, usually pulls in 200 or so shooters from several states and Canada, though because of the lock down the Canadian contingent hasn't been able to attend for the last two. Those guys are not only great guys but they are some really fine shooters. There are also a bunch of side events. They are fifty target venues for 410, 28, 20, 12, pump, s x s, a 100 target prelim, and a Make A Break. Make a Break is a very very interesting game. Two shooters on a platform. Eleven traps on the field, two number ones and then 2 thru 10. Traps are shot in order. At the shooters call he will get a number one target from either of the two number ones. On report he will get the number 2 target. If both are hit and broken the shooter gets 3 points. The number one target must be broken. If it isn't, better get it on your second shot for 1 point. If number 1 is missed and number 2 is broken score zero. You MUST break number 1 or you miss out. So as you advance to say trap 5 and you get both targets you score 6 points.Shooters alternate. As the trap number escalates so does the difficulty of the shot. Number 10 is always a real good poke. Half way thru shooters switch sides on the platform. They also run a 50 target FITASC event (Sporting Clays for big boys). Historically it has always been a 12 ga game but this year it has been expanded to 20 and 28 ga. Some very strict rules here. The butt of the gun must be started below a line 10 cm from the top of the shoulder. Once you take your set point and call for the bird the gun can not move until the target is visible. There are usually 5 or 6 traps per parcours (field) with 3 pegs or shooting positions which are 1 meter in diameter. The shooter is allowed to attempt targets in any direction and can ask his squad mates and the ref to move. You will shoot singles then reports and finally pairs. Everyone will shoot their singles, then shooters will rotate order and shoot reports, rotate and attempt pairs. You are allowed full use of the gun, never more than 2 shells. The shooter calls for the target at which time the ref blows a whistle to release the target. Factory ammo only, no hand loads. 12 ga 1 ounce (28 gram) only, 20 ga 7/8 ounce, and 28 is 3/4 ounce. All targets will be demonstrated. Chokes may only be changed outside of the hoop before shooting commences. You may change them at the next hoop. Before shooting you may track a flight path with your hand never ever the gun. Once shooting on that hoop has started no tracking is allowed. Coaching from squad mates is not allowed and you must be 3 feet or more away from the shooter. A shooter will typically get a warning for a movement of the gun, second offence, lost target.
|
|
|
Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: sako22]
#7266412
05/17/21 07:48 PM
05/17/21 07:48 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 3,112 7mtns of CENTRAL PA
GROUSEWIT
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 3,112
7mtns of CENTRAL PA
|
I have had 2 berretta 682 gold E o/u. They were both very nice guns. The trap combo I bought at Jaquae's I had sent straight back to the factory for a left hand stock swap More left handers on here than right!! My 682X was cast on for lefthander!!!
NRALIFER,PRPA LIFER,HUNTER,FURTAKER
|
|
|
Re: Let's talk over under shotguns
[Re: nvwrangler]
#7266886
05/18/21 12:00 PM
05/18/21 12:00 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 715 Michigan
BigBlackBirds
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 715
Michigan
|
BigBlackBirds, no I didn't. I haven't shot it for a few years. I started reffing several years ago. I am an NSCA certified Sporting ref, so instead of paying $1.00 plus a target and getting to watch 4 or 5 other shooters in my squad that I may or may not learn anything from, I get paid $80.00 a day to watch about 200 shooters better than half of which I can learn something from. I take my pay in targets. It's a 3 day shoot and I haven't payed for any targets in a few years. Plus my competition days are behind me. My eyes and reflexes aren't what they used to be. I'm 70 years old and lugging an 8 to 9 pound gun, 6 boxes of shells, and my shooting bag just doesn't have the thrill that it used to. That course is a mile and a half give or take and I refuse to rent one of their golf carts. IMHO a golf cart is an unfair advantage and it's an obnoxious distraction to a shooter in the box that's trying to concentrate on his task at hand. If a shooter is disabled that's another story and the cart is justified. I'm not there quite yet. Besides, I'll be able to go on Wednesday and shoot the same targets off my card which at last check still held about 1300 or so targets. That shoot, the Spring Deuce, usually pulls in 200 or so shooters from several states and Canada, though because of the lock down the Canadian contingent hasn't been able to attend for the last two. Those guys are not only great guys but they are some really fine shooters. There are also a bunch of side events. They are fifty target venues for 410, 28, 20, 12, pump, s x s, a 100 target prelim, and a Make A Break. Make a Break is a very very interesting game. Two shooters on a platform. Eleven traps on the field, two number ones and then 2 thru 10. Traps are shot in order. At the shooters call he will get a number one target from either of the two number ones. On report he will get the number 2 target. If both are hit and broken the shooter gets 3 points. The number one target must be broken. If it isn't, better get it on your second shot for 1 point. If number 1 is missed and number 2 is broken score zero. You MUST break number 1 or you miss out. So as you advance to say trap 5 and you get both targets you score 6 points.Shooters alternate. As the trap number escalates so does the difficulty of the shot. Number 10 is always a real good poke. Half way thru shooters switch sides on the platform. They also run a 50 target FITASC event (Sporting Clays for big boys). Historically it has always been a 12 ga game but this year it has been expanded to 20 and 28 ga. Some very strict rules here. The butt of the gun must be started below a line 10 cm from the top of the shoulder. Once you take your set point and call for the bird the gun can not move until the target is visible. There are usually 5 or 6 traps per parcours (field) with 3 pegs or shooting positions which are 1 meter in diameter. The shooter is allowed to attempt targets in any direction and can ask his squad mates and the ref to move. You will shoot singles then reports and finally pairs. Everyone will shoot their singles, then shooters will rotate order and shoot reports, rotate and attempt pairs. You are allowed full use of the gun, never more than 2 shells. The shooter calls for the target at which time the ref blows a whistle to release the target. Factory ammo only, no hand loads. 12 ga 1 ounce (28 gram) only, 20 ga 7/8 ounce, and 28 is 3/4 ounce. All targets will be demonstrated. Chokes may only be changed outside of the hoop before shooting commences. You may change them at the next hoop. Before shooting you may track a flight path with your hand never ever the gun. Once shooting on that hoop has started no tracking is allowed. Coaching from squad mates is not allowed and you must be 3 feet or more away from the shooter. A shooter will typically get a warning for a movement of the gun, second offence, lost target. Paul- Out east, M&M is the only place I've shot and that's been awhile back. I've heard Rochester Brooks is a nice course. I havent been going much in the last few years. Just not enough time and as get older my eyes have been changing about every 6 months which has been completely annoying. Normally I'd shoot Northbrook in Illinois or Bald Mountain/Island Lake closer to home. Those two Michigan courses (both state owned/public courses but privately managed) were holding alot of registered sporting events in the past but more recently they've been concentrating on registered FITASC and Super Sporting. Prior to covid border restrictions there had been a sizable group from Canada regularly attending. Bald Mountain frequently holds the state shoot as its a decent sized area with some varied terrain on a mile plus main course with seperate sub gauge course. Normally the main course holds 4 machines per station with two set fairly soft for the public and two not so soft. There's always a high percentage of those that are strictly hard core tournament targets as both courses get alot of practice from those attending regionals, etc. You can always tell when its been set up for serious practice as the distances grow while the lines become more technical and subtle.
|
|
|
|
|