No Profanity *** No Flaming *** No Advertising *** No Anti Trappers ***NO POLITICS
No Non-Target Catches *** No Links to Anti-trapping Sites *** No Avoiding Profanity Filter


Home~Trap Talk~ADC Forum~Trap Shed~Wilderness Trapping~International Trappers~Fur Handling

Auction Forum~Trapper Tips~Links~Gallery~Basic Sets~Convention Calendar~Chat~ Trap Collecting Forum

Trapper's Humor~Strictly Trapping~Fur Buyers Directory~Mugshots~Fur Sale Directory~Wildcrafting~The Pen and Quill

Trapper's Tales~Words From The Past~Legends~Archives~Kids Forum~Lure Formulators Forum~ Fermenter's Forum


~~~ Dobbins' Products Catalog ~~~


Minnesota Trapline Products
Please support our sponsor for the Trappers Talk Page - Minnesota Trapline Products


Print Thread
Hop To
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Muley or Whitetail..? #8687181
11/12/26 04:25 PM
11/12/26 04:25 PM
Joined: Nov 2012
midland, michigan
M
midlander Offline OP
trapper
midlander  Offline OP
trapper
M

Joined: Nov 2012
midland, michigan
Never eaten muley, is it similar to whitetail....better or worse? What say you to those that have had both...?

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687183
11/12/26 04:26 PM
11/12/26 04:26 PM
Joined: Mar 2007
McGrath, AK
W
white17 Offline

"General (Mr.Sunshine) Washington"
white17  Offline

"General (Mr.Sunshine) Washington"
W

Joined: Mar 2007
McGrath, AK
Whitetail hands down !


Mean As Nails
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687184
11/12/26 04:30 PM
11/12/26 04:30 PM
Joined: Feb 2026
SE Ohio
B
Beaver Knocker Offline
trapper
Beaver Knocker  Offline
trapper
B

Joined: Feb 2026
SE Ohio
I've never had muley, but I just had a buddy that shot one, and he seems to like the muley. He shot it in Montana.


Sure, I'm a member of PETA! People Eating Tasty Animals!
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687186
11/12/26 04:32 PM
11/12/26 04:32 PM
Joined: Aug 2011
Craigmont, Idaho
M
marty weatherup Offline
trapper
marty weatherup  Offline
trapper
M

Joined: Aug 2011
Craigmont, Idaho
I have both in the wheat land I live in and can’t say I can tell a bit of difference. I’ve had both from timber country and can’t tell any difference between them. They taste different than the crop land deer. The crop land deer seem to taste better than the timber land deer. At least to me. And if they come out of the same kind of ground, I can’t tell any difference between them. I guess my palate isn’t educated well enough.


Trail cameras and fresh snow have broke a lot of trapper’s hearts.
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687192
11/12/26 04:42 PM
11/12/26 04:42 PM
Joined: Jul 2011
Custer SD
A
arcticotter Offline
trapper
arcticotter  Offline
trapper
A

Joined: Jul 2011
Custer SD
Eaten lots of both. All depends what they are eating and the timing of the animal harvested. Had good and bad of both. Process all my own meat.

Last edited by arcticotter; 11/12/26 04:42 PM.
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: white17] #8687198
11/12/26 04:52 PM
11/12/26 04:52 PM
Joined: Dec 2006
Northern Maine
Bruce T Offline
trapper
Bruce T  Offline
trapper

Joined: Dec 2006
Northern Maine
Originally Posted by white17
Whitetail hands down !

I have only shot 1 mule deer but I agree


NRA,NTA,MTA,FTA

Proud member of NTA
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687199
11/12/26 04:55 PM
11/12/26 04:55 PM
Joined: Dec 2006
Very SE Nebraska
G
Gary Benson Offline
trapper
Gary Benson  Offline
trapper
G

Joined: Dec 2006
Very SE Nebraska
Whitetail generally because of diet but some mulies also eat a good diet of corn, beans, alfalfa. They are just as good.


Life ain't supposed to be easy.
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687206
11/12/26 05:20 PM
11/12/26 05:20 PM
Joined: Dec 2006
Three Lakes,WI 75
C
corky Offline
trapper
corky  Offline
trapper
C

Joined: Dec 2006
Three Lakes,WI 75
As stated, it depends on the deer's diet and care of the meat. I've had alfalfa and grain fed muleys as well as corn fed whitetails. All were superior to the tamarack swamp whitetails we have locally in the northwoods.


http://www.usdebtclock.org/
This place is getting more like Facebook every day.

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687208
11/12/26 05:25 PM
11/12/26 05:25 PM
Joined: Feb 2017
Priest River, Idaho USA
S
SundanceMtnMan Offline
trapper
SundanceMtnMan  Offline
trapper
S

Joined: Feb 2017
Priest River, Idaho USA
I have shot and eaten lots of both. If shot in the same area and taken care of the same way I can't tell any different.


"They Say Nothing is Impossible,
But, I Do Nothing Every Day."
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687224
11/12/26 06:13 PM
11/12/26 06:13 PM
Joined: Jan 2007
NW Wyoming
W
wyote Offline
trapper
wyote  Offline
trapper
W

Joined: Jan 2007
NW Wyoming
I prefer whitetails.


For every law thats passed, alittle freedom dies
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687239
11/12/26 07:06 PM
11/12/26 07:06 PM
Joined: Jan 2018
MN
Donnersurvivor Offline
trapper
Donnersurvivor  Offline
trapper

Joined: Jan 2018
MN
I have shot a pile of whitetails and several mule deer, taste the same to me.


Originally Posted by yotetrapper30
by and large, you're right. Women are almost always awful.

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: marty weatherup] #8687317
11/12/26 09:51 PM
11/12/26 09:51 PM
Joined: Oct 2011
Idaho
B
bearcat2 Offline
trapper
bearcat2  Offline
trapper
B

Joined: Oct 2011
Idaho
Originally Posted by marty weatherup
I have both in the wheat land I live in and can’t say I can tell a bit of difference. I’ve had both from timber country and can’t tell any difference between them. They taste different than the crop land deer. The crop land deer seem to taste better than the timber land deer. At least to me. And if they come out of the same kind of ground, I can’t tell any difference between them. I guess my palate isn’t educated well enough.


Personally I prefer the timber country deer. A lot better flavor in my opinion, those grain fed deer taste like beef! I like mule deer because there is more meat on them, in my opinion, if they are eating the same thing, they taste the same as whitetails... unless they are rutted up. Muleys get a lot ranker in the rut than whitetail do, not as rank as blacktail, but a lot stronger than a rutted up whitetail. I've been told the reason I like mule deer is because we don't have real mule deer, because they don't eat sage. Having never eaten a muley that is living on sage brush, I can't comment on that.

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687419
11/13/26 08:42 AM
11/13/26 08:42 AM
Joined: Jan 2008
Alaska and Washington State
W
waggler Offline
trapper
waggler  Offline
trapper
W

Joined: Jan 2008
Alaska and Washington State
Never shot a mule deer, but some muly meat I've been given a couple of times was not great; they were both shot in sage country.
I've shot one whitetail, it was good.
I've shot scores of blactail, a close relative of mule deer, and I've never had one that wasn't great.


"My life is better than your vacation"
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687464
11/13/26 10:32 AM
11/13/26 10:32 AM
Joined: Feb 2020
Wyoming
wytex Offline
trapper
wytex  Offline
trapper

Joined: Feb 2020
Wyoming
Our muley bucks from this year are great eating, we did age them for 10 days though.
They were not quite in the rut yet and do not have ag feed, they are open country- mountain bucks.

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687560
11/13/26 02:10 PM
11/13/26 02:10 PM
Joined: Sep 2010
NE
M
Marty B Offline
"arbitrary noob"
Marty B  Offline
"arbitrary noob"
M

Joined: Sep 2010
NE
I bet in a blind taste test, very few, if any could yell the difference.

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687636
11/13/26 05:31 PM
11/13/26 05:31 PM
Joined: Apr 2025
W central MN
K
K9sniper1 Offline
trapper
K9sniper1  Offline
trapper
K

Joined: Apr 2025
W central MN
To a man those in my hunting party like muleys from NW SD better than MN whitetail. Cut the hock glands off right away

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687640
11/13/26 05:35 PM
11/13/26 05:35 PM
Joined: Dec 2006
Oregon
beaverpeeler Offline
trapper
beaverpeeler  Offline
trapper

Joined: Dec 2006
Oregon
..and eat those first?


My fear of moving stairs is escalating!
Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687667
11/13/26 06:22 PM
11/13/26 06:22 PM
Joined: Mar 2010
SD
Boone Liane Offline
trapper
Boone Liane  Offline
trapper

Joined: Mar 2010
SD
38 years of killing deer and this was hands down the BEST eating deer I’ve ever had!

But it was more a function of being able to let him hang at near optimal temps for two full weeks.

I only cut him when I did because it was gonna freeze hard.

[Linked Image]

Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687699
11/13/26 07:17 PM
11/13/26 07:17 PM
Joined: Dec 2006
Minnesota
330-Trapper Offline

trapper
330-Trapper  Offline

trapper

Joined: Dec 2006
Minnesota
Originally Posted by midlander
Never eaten muley, is it similar to whitetail....better or worse? What say you to those that have had both...?


Depends on the Deer...
Alpha bottoms or Sage

i've eaten a lot of meal deer in my time.And I think it's equal


NRA Life Member






Re: Muley or Whitetail..? [Re: midlander] #8687718
11/13/26 07:51 PM
11/13/26 07:51 PM
Joined: Dec 2022
North Central WA.
J
Jingles Offline
trapper
Jingles  Offline
trapper
J

Joined: Dec 2022
North Central WA.
Nice looking 3 x 3 congrats


No man is entitled to the Blessings of Freedom unless he be vigilant in it's preservation
D. MacArthur
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Previous Thread
Index
Next Thread