Mmtrapper....because some of us actually care about the comfort and well being of the animal. Even if we're gonna kill it in the end, we owe it to the coyote to make it as painless as possible. I don't know about the rest of you, but when I see a critter with a messed up paw it upsets me. I don't want to cause an animal unnecessary pain.

The "right trap" for any species depends on the methods used to catch that particular animal, and method depends on geographical location, climate, etc. As Mark pointed out, it's all about variables, and when those variables come together harmoniously you've got a formula for success.

So arguing about which trap is best for coyotes in isolation, without taking into consideration the methods used to catch those (particular) coyotes, is not very productive. I think you'll find that those who use very different sized traps for the same species, and are successful, will employ different methods based on their own set of conditions - aka variables.

Anyway, I hope Mark returns. I've never used his lures before, but I will now. I think his honest engagement with fellow trappers here and elsewhere boosts his credibility, and I appreciate that. Thank you, Mark!

Somebody send me 6 of each so i can test them and post my opinion:) I use #3 victor softcatch right now for lynx, red fox and occasional wolverine. Checking out the #3 and #4 victor offset forged jaw. They look like they would work well up here. Has anybody switched the softcatch jaws out for the offset jaws? Cheaper than buying new traps.