For a short while in late '81 and early '82 my Bride and I lived a short distance from that spot. We rented an "apartment" in the old converted motel located on the very west edge of town, just past the Maverick Station on the road to Rigby.

Can't tell ya what or where my first fish was caught, but could lead you to the very spot I caught my first coyote, and that was sixty years ago, last fall! I remember the important stuff! lol

Bluegill and sunfish out of the creek with my dad and grandma. Forty years or so ago.

not sure ? I would say a Bullhead

Great stories thanks for sharing.
For those with kids & grandkids what was their first fish?

chubs

My first fish caught was a Pumpkinseed Sunfish. A pretty big one. I was fishing with my step Grandfather and messed up the cast. It landed about three feet out and this big pumpkinseed came up and grabbed it. I haven't thought of that in years. I had to be 6-8 probably.

Yellow Perch during spring runs.