Re: Roll Tide
[Re: jbyrd63]
#8010677
12/03/23 07:54 PM
12/03/23 07:54 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 8,591 western mn
bucksnbears
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 8,591
western mn
|
Maybe. Sorry if I gave you credit you didn’t deserve. I got to put my glasses on when I read this Looks like clown boy was right on who should be in !!! Boom mic drop !!! Nother edit....
swampgas chili and schmidt beer makes for a deadly combo
You have to remember that 1 out of 3 Democratic Voters is just as dumb as the other two.
|
|
|
Re: Roll Tide
[Re: jbyrd63]
#8010761
12/03/23 08:42 PM
12/03/23 08:42 PM
|
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 14,467 Central Pennsylvania
Nittany Lion
Don't call me Mister, Mister
|
Don't call me Mister, Mister
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 14,467
Central Pennsylvania
|
I copied and pasted this article from PennLive.com's sports writer David Jones.
The 13-member College Football Playoff committee was unquestionably faced with the most challenging task in the decade-long history of the event. But I don’t think they had the collective stomach for snubbing the SEC, a solution suggested by many on Sunday morning.
That’s the first of my five takeaways from Sunday’s College Football Playoff reveal:
1. The SEC remains the most powerful bloc in the game.
By any measure, this was the least impressive season on the field in recent memory for the nation’s most successful conference. The SEC won only 7 times against P5 competition, and none was what you’d call a wow result.
The SEC’s best win was arguably from among these
• Mississippi’s 37-20 victory over Tulane.
• Kentucky’s 38-31 win at Louisville.
• Mississippi State’s 31-24 overtime win over Arizona.
• Missouri’s 30-27 win over Kansas State.
Further, the SEC dropped a lot of marquee matchups:
• Alabama lost 34-24 at home to Texas.
• Louisiana State lost 45-24 to Florida State.
• Texas A&M lost 48-33 at Miami.
• Florida lost 24-11 at Utah.
• Arkansas lost 38-31 to Brigham Young.
• South Carolina lost 31-17 to North Carolina.
• South Carolina also lost 16-7 to Clemson.
Then, there were some unsightly narrow wins and ugly losses:
• Auburn won 14-10 at California.
• Alabama won 17-3 at South Florida (led 10-3 late).
• Georgia won 31-23 at Georgia Tech.
• Auburn lost 31-10 to New Mexico State (the week before it took Alabama to the last play).
• Vanderbilt lost 36-20 at Wake Forest.
• Vanderbilt also lost 40-37 at UNLV.
Even the staunchest SEC fans would quietly admit since about midseason this was by no means a vintage year for the league.
And yet, somehow the national media narrative perpetuated that the SEC’s strength was unmatched, that its results could stack up against anyone.
That apparently extended to the 13-person CFP committee which easily could have used Florida State’s rout of LSU as a linchpin of its case to be in the field, yet turned a blind eye.
Instead, CFP committee chair Boo Corrigan trotted out the excuse that FSU wasn’t the same since its starting QB Jordan Travis broke his left leg two weeks ago against North Alabama. Yes, FSU’s offense struggled in wins at in-state rival Florida and in the ACC championship game against Louisville. But the Seminoles won the games.
The only conclusion I can reach is that committee members feared repercussions had they snubbed both Georgia and Alabama and left the SEC entirely outside the rope for the first time in the Playoff’s 10-year history.
You cannot tell me that if you swapped out FSU’s garnet and gold for Bama’s crimson and white that the wins away from home over Florida and Louisville wouldn’t be suddenly considered the gutty, gritty overcoming of adversity. That Nick Saban wouldn’t be hailed as a resourceful leader of men who found a way to get his team across the finish line unblemished.
(This word is unacceptable on Trapperman), if it had been Bama playing with its 3rd-string QB and the other team was LSU, suddenly that 16-6 slogfest would be considered one of the great old-school defensive struggles of the modern era, the way football ought to be played.
It’s this simple: the committee members were terrified of crossing the SEC. And Saban. And Greg Sankey. And Paul Feinbaum. And Laura Rutledge’s makeup. And the whole lot of Disney’s SEC-aligned cabal. They were never, ever doing that.
And that sucks.
2. Thank heavens no more of the 4-team bracket.
It should have and could have been a 12-team tournament this year instead of next. The fact that the 4-team model existed only when 5 power conferences existed and now vanishes the moment the Pac-12 dissolves is ironic enough. As soon as they don’t desperately need more than four slots with the Pac-12′s demise and now only four major conferences, then they expand the Playoff threefold.
Sure, the arguments over #12 and #13 will be lively in the future. But they’ll be much more muted, in the same way pundits momentarily consider who’s snubbed from the NCAA basketball bracket and then quickly move on.
It’ll be a different sort of obsequiousness from the committee next year when some 9-3 SEC team gets in over a more deserving lesser-conference outfit. But at least it can’t be this egregious again.
3. Florida State’s exclusion is also a shot over the ACC’s bow.
This wasn’t merely a snubbing of the unbeaten Seminoles in favor of once-beaten Alabama. This was a repudiation of the Atlantic Coast Conference as a whole in a way that cannot be mistaken. It’s as if the bulk of the committee members rejected the idea of the ACC as a power conference altogether.
And that is akin to telling its strongest members: Look, you’re in a rinky-dink league. As soon as your lawyers manage to locate a legal loophole in the ACC’s grant of rights – that is, a manageable buyout – better evacuate for the SEC or B1G as soon as you can.
Florida State and Clemson both reportedly examined jumping from the ACC last year, but couldn’t get it done. FSU’s spurning by the CFP after a 13-0 season must send the message: Your conference schedule isn’t good enough.
I got myself a seniors' GPS. Not only does it tell me how to get to my destination, it tells me why I wanted to go there.
|
|
|
Re: Roll Tide
[Re: ScottW]
#8010852
12/03/23 09:44 PM
12/03/23 09:44 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2020
Posts: 5,506 Aliceville, Kansas 44
Yukon John
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jan 2020
Posts: 5,506
Aliceville, Kansas 44
|
I knew Alabama would squeak in somehow after Auburn gifted them that victory. I was so mad when I saw how they won…..I haven’t watched much of any in college football this year, but I know Bama was eekin one out seemingly every week. Maybe they got better as the year went on, but was sure hoping we could’ve had some more fresh meat, but I’ll take TX and WA over GA and the rest of the usuals. I do t have any kinda dog in the fight, but I’m pulling hard for Washington/Michigan championship and WA to win it all! Happy trapping! ScottW That would be GLORIOUS!
Act like a blank, get treated like a blank. Insert your own blank!
|
|
|
Re: Roll Tide
[Re: Nittany Lion]
#8010902
12/03/23 10:39 PM
12/03/23 10:39 PM
|
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 18,321 Oakland, MS
yotetrapper30
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 18,321
Oakland, MS
|
I copied and pasted this article from PennLive.com's sports writer David Jones.
The 13-member College Football Playoff committee was unquestionably faced with the most challenging task in the decade-long history of the event. But I don’t think they had the collective stomach for snubbing the SEC, a solution suggested by many on Sunday morning.
That’s the first of my five takeaways from Sunday’s College Football Playoff reveal:
1. The SEC remains the most powerful bloc in the game.
By any measure, this was the least impressive season on the field in recent memory for the nation’s most successful conference. The SEC won only 7 times against P5 competition, and none was what you’d call a wow result.
The SEC’s best win was arguably from among these
• Mississippi’s 37-20 victory over Tulane.
• Kentucky’s 38-31 win at Louisville.
• Mississippi State’s 31-24 overtime win over Arizona.
• Missouri’s 30-27 win over Kansas State.
Further, the SEC dropped a lot of marquee matchups:
• Alabama lost 34-24 at home to Texas.
• Louisiana State lost 45-24 to Florida State.
• Texas A&M lost 48-33 at Miami.
• Florida lost 24-11 at Utah.
• Arkansas lost 38-31 to Brigham Young.
• South Carolina lost 31-17 to North Carolina.
• South Carolina also lost 16-7 to Clemson.
Then, there were some unsightly narrow wins and ugly losses:
• Auburn won 14-10 at California.
• Alabama won 17-3 at South Florida (led 10-3 late).
• Georgia won 31-23 at Georgia Tech.
• Auburn lost 31-10 to New Mexico State (the week before it took Alabama to the last play).
• Vanderbilt lost 36-20 at Wake Forest.
• Vanderbilt also lost 40-37 at UNLV.
Even the staunchest SEC fans would quietly admit since about midseason this was by no means a vintage year for the league.
And yet, somehow the national media narrative perpetuated that the SEC’s strength was unmatched, that its results could stack up against anyone.
That apparently extended to the 13-person CFP committee which easily could have used Florida State’s rout of LSU as a linchpin of its case to be in the field, yet turned a blind eye.
Instead, CFP committee chair Boo Corrigan trotted out the excuse that FSU wasn’t the same since its starting QB Jordan Travis broke his left leg two weeks ago against North Alabama. Yes, FSU’s offense struggled in wins at in-state rival Florida and in the ACC championship game against Louisville. But the Seminoles won the games.
The only conclusion I can reach is that committee members feared repercussions had they snubbed both Georgia and Alabama and left the SEC entirely outside the rope for the first time in the Playoff’s 10-year history.
You cannot tell me that if you swapped out FSU’s garnet and gold for Bama’s crimson and white that the wins away from home over Florida and Louisville wouldn’t be suddenly considered the gutty, gritty overcoming of adversity. That Nick Saban wouldn’t be hailed as a resourceful leader of men who found a way to get his team across the finish line unblemished.
(This word is unacceptable on Trapperman), if it had been Bama playing with its 3rd-string QB and the other team was LSU, suddenly that 16-6 slogfest would be considered one of the great old-school defensive struggles of the modern era, the way football ought to be played.
It’s this simple: the committee members were terrified of crossing the SEC. And Saban. And Greg Sankey. And Paul Feinbaum. And Laura Rutledge’s makeup. And the whole lot of Disney’s SEC-aligned cabal. They were never, ever doing that.
And that sucks.
2. Thank heavens no more of the 4-team bracket.
It should have and could have been a 12-team tournament this year instead of next. The fact that the 4-team model existed only when 5 power conferences existed and now vanishes the moment the Pac-12 dissolves is ironic enough. As soon as they don’t desperately need more than four slots with the Pac-12′s demise and now only four major conferences, then they expand the Playoff threefold.
Sure, the arguments over #12 and #13 will be lively in the future. But they’ll be much more muted, in the same way pundits momentarily consider who’s snubbed from the NCAA basketball bracket and then quickly move on.
It’ll be a different sort of obsequiousness from the committee next year when some 9-3 SEC team gets in over a more deserving lesser-conference outfit. But at least it can’t be this egregious again.
3. Florida State’s exclusion is also a shot over the ACC’s bow.
This wasn’t merely a snubbing of the unbeaten Seminoles in favor of once-beaten Alabama. This was a repudiation of the Atlantic Coast Conference as a whole in a way that cannot be mistaken. It’s as if the bulk of the committee members rejected the idea of the ACC as a power conference altogether.
And that is akin to telling its strongest members: Look, you’re in a rinky-dink league. As soon as your lawyers manage to locate a legal loophole in the ACC’s grant of rights – that is, a manageable buyout – better evacuate for the SEC or B1G as soon as you can.
Florida State and Clemson both reportedly examined jumping from the ACC last year, but couldn’t get it done. FSU’s spurning by the CFP after a 13-0 season must send the message: Your conference schedule isn’t good enough. So what are you going to say when an SEC team still goes to the championship next year? Because undoubtedly either Bama or Georgia will. Maybe both.
Just give me one thing, that I can hold on to. To believe in this livin' is just a hard way to go.
|
|
|
Re: Roll Tide
[Re: jbyrd63]
#8011056
12/04/23 07:18 AM
12/04/23 07:18 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 21,726 Alabama (Bama for short) 108 y...
Jtrapper
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 21,726
Alabama (Bama for short) 108 y...
|
Don't like seeing an SEC win it all every year, build your program up! Dabbo did that for a few years at Clemson, being in the ACC with their weak puny teams he had a free ride every year to the play off's. Now's he's fell off the cliff with all this NIL and tranfer portal crap going on.
But yea, more games next year but your going to end up with the usual's all over again plus Texas will be an SEC team as well, maybe puny little SEC won't be so weak next season with them and OK. in, lol.
Not my circus, not my clowns.
|
|
|
Re: Roll Tide
[Re: jbyrd63]
#8011318
12/04/23 12:24 PM
12/04/23 12:24 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 281 Smithsburg, MD
J.C.
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 281
Smithsburg, MD
|
College football is a racket. The decision-making of who is best is shady. There are virtually no student-athletes on these teams. They are groomed since a young age and can barely read at a 6th grade level for the most part. The best schools are football vocational schools and they should just start a minor league for the NFL.
To a person ignorant of nature, his country stroll is a walk through a gallery filled with wonderful works of art with their faces turned to the wall
|
|
|
Re: Roll Tide
[Re: hippie]
#8011429
12/04/23 02:34 PM
12/04/23 02:34 PM
|
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 14,467 Central Pennsylvania
Nittany Lion
Don't call me Mister, Mister
|
Don't call me Mister, Mister
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 14,467
Central Pennsylvania
|
With a 12 team playoff, are they giving the top 4 teams a bye to make the math work? Yes.
I got myself a seniors' GPS. Not only does it tell me how to get to my destination, it tells me why I wanted to go there.
|
|
|
|
|