I think they probably speared or clubbed them. It can be done, because I’ve done it.
In certain situations, alligator garfish behave in such a way that it makes being able to get in close pretty easy. In my experience this has either been when they’re corralled into shallow waters or has been when water is flowing through a tight spot such as a culvert or something similar. I think they group up and sit there because baitfish are funneled through the choke point. When this happens, you can easily watch or get pretty close to them over and over, consistently.
Another way to get very close to garfish is by using light on a dark night, an example being lights on a dock. We’ve done this before with frog grabbers catching smaller garfish. With that said, maybe they used a torch as a light to get them close to the surface? Probably not, but I suppose it’s possible.
With gar populations no doubt being greater in those times, it is my opinion that opportunities to get garfish were likely common. Garfish are very well armored with the exception of the back of the head right behind the eyes. I know for a fact that a blow landed on this spot will instantly turn out their light, and if I can do it, I believe they could have done it as well.
Alligator garfish are an incredible animal, and in my opinion when it comes to freshwater fishes, alligator garfish is second to none when it comes to eating them. I fry gar steaks or slabs like pork chops, or I take the flesh and combine it with seasoned tater tots 60/40, batter and fry to make delicious gar patties.
Last edited by Aix sponsa; 02/21/24 06:44 PM.