Jbyrd63, I did drill a hole in lowest spot and drained more water than expected. Took longer for it to freeze up again.
Cooler is empty right now. I ran it all day yesterday at a low temp to see when it would freeze again. It was about 38* inside when it frosted back up. The controller was set at 28. I shut it down to thaw and will adjust up to get it back to 42* inside. I'll also adjust AC fan. It was turning on/off just fine before. I suppose it could be a coolant issue.
And why would you not eat the deer, or give it to someone? They are perfectly fine to consume. We wouldn't shoot them if they were going to be wasted (although someone else probably would).
Further research suggests the AC works much better with two controllers, so may just order another. They're only $36.
Scrapper, the insulation is fine, it's a cooler that came out of a restaurant many years ago, and had been in use with a different AC for 35 years. The other AC was commercial with freon, andworkedgreat, It just wasn't feasible to continue using it in my basement without a lot of work and upgrade.
Our crop damage permits allow us to kill all deer, buck, doe, fawn. Although we have four tags, as soon as we report a kill, we automatically have four tags again. So it's unlimited. My permit is for my cousin's farm, corn crops for their cattle. My friend's permit is a different property that grows large amounts of assorted vegetables. One bite is lost profits.
Thank you all for the info/suggestions.