Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363155
03/12/25 08:30 PM
03/12/25 08:30 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2007
MN
160user
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jan 2007
MN
|
Wolves are adaptive, they find ways to survive on a new food source when traditional ones dry up. There was an interesting study done in SE on an island where the wolves have almost or completely eradicated the deer population, so the wolves started hunting sea otters. Not a one time opportunistic type of thing, but actually adjusted their diet and hunting methods to effectively eat sea otters Good info. This is a "suspicion" of what may be happening here, in some areas. My buddy has a trail cam in the midst of wolf territory here. Once with many deer, He hasn't seen a deer on his camera the entire last year. The beaver ponds in that specific area have dried up. It's also a gated Co-op community. The local beaver trapper stated he hasn't trapped any. Have the wolves become that effective? Many of the ponds around here that have had beaver in them most of my life are empty this year. I trapped a couple of them last winter and due to the low water the beaver had "tunnels" rather than runs from the house to the feed pile. Because of drought, I believe many of the smaller ponds (2 year olds) have froze out due to lack of snow for insulation. The big, deep ponds still seem to be holding plenty of beaver. Just my 2 cents worth.
I have nothing clever to put here.
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363168
03/12/25 08:46 PM
03/12/25 08:46 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2010
virginia,MN
beavert
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jan 2010
virginia,MN
|
I trap beaver and have a cabin right next to voyagers national park. 15 years ago every curve you came around on forest roads in the area deer would be jumping off the road, now it’s a rare sighting. If you drove up highway 53 between cook and international falls there were deer feeding all over the road right of way, now not hardly at all.
If you go into crane lake or ash river near “town” there are some deer around, also same in my rural neighborhood just north of Virginia, get around houses and there are deer, go in the woods not many deer. The deer hang near homes for safety.
5-8 years ago every ditch, pond, flowage, lake, etc. were loaded with beaver, literally beaver everywhere, nuisance and usda trappers were hitting them hard all summer and still every fall and spring us trappers in the area were taking plenty of beaver no problem. Now don’t get me wrong there are still a lot of beaver in the voyagers ecosystem but there are way less numbers than before along with way less trapping (fur prices, older guys dying/not capable). I ride snowmobile up flowages and see dry colony after dry colony big meadows of grass that once were huge beaver ponds, areas that no one can even get to during open water, sad to see. There was a t-man member from the UP (don’t remember his name) commented about how he watched the wolves eat all the deer then eat all the beaver and I am watching it happen here as well. It sucks! Don’t forget bears! there are a heckofalot more bears up here now than ever!
Last edited by beavert; 03/12/25 08:54 PM.
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363176
03/12/25 08:52 PM
03/12/25 08:52 PM
|
Joined: May 2010
MN
Steven 49er
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: May 2010
MN
|
Things ebb and things flow. I remember growing up there wasn't many wolves and we had a limit of 10 Beaver.
I remember we didn't have a spring beaver season and couldn't sit near a beaver house or with an x amount of feet of a dam.
Then it decided to rain for 10 years with quite a bit of snow we had beavers.
I don't know about northeastern Minnesota but I can say a lot of the areas that I trapped are 4 ft lower than they were 15 years ago. We are drying up. If it doesn't rain this summer, we're in trouble
"Gold is money, everything else is just credit" JP Morgan
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363179
03/12/25 08:54 PM
03/12/25 08:54 PM
|
Joined: May 2010
MN
Steven 49er
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: May 2010
MN
|
Beavert brings up another good point. There's a lot of beaver getting bountied Or trapped by the USDA that never used to be.
"Gold is money, everything else is just credit" JP Morgan
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: AK Timber Tramp]
#8363210
03/12/25 09:39 PM
03/12/25 09:39 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2008
Alaska and Washington State
waggler
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jan 2008
Alaska and Washington State
|
Wolves are adaptive, they find ways to survive on a new food source when traditional ones dry up. There was an interesting study done in SE on an island where the wolves have almost or completely eradicated the deer population, so the wolves started hunting sea otters. Not a one time opportunistic type of thing, but actually adjusted their diet and hunting methods to effectively eat sea otters They are probably the most adaptive animal there is, next to humans. 25 years ago I was trapping out of Hyder Alaska, 90 miles inland up the Portland Canal; not your typical SE Alaska weather. There was six feet of snow on the beach, no deer in that area, and very little of anything else for wolves to eat, The wolves were cruising down the beach at low tide and flipping over rocks, eating blennies and any other little morsels they could find under the rocks.
"My life is better than your vacation"
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363212
03/12/25 09:41 PM
03/12/25 09:41 PM
|
Joined: Sep 2007
South metro, MN
Calvin
OP
trapper
|
OP
trapper
Joined: Sep 2007
South metro, MN
|
I didn't realize the Northeast part of the state suffered the same drought the rest of us did the last few years. Clearly that could be a contributing factor.
Trapdog1. The wolf range is the in the Northeast part of Minnesota. Some will roam out of that area to a degree but that's what they consider the "Wolf Range" where the bulk of the population is.
Last edited by Calvin; 03/12/25 09:41 PM.
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363215
03/12/25 09:47 PM
03/12/25 09:47 PM
|
Joined: Nov 2023
Lake Mille Lacs , MN
2poor
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Nov 2023
Lake Mille Lacs , MN
|
I can’t recall losing a single Beaver to wolves.
Had Bear take beaver from trap or with trap at least a 1/2 dozen times. I don’t think I have set a Beaver trap in anything other then Wolf country in an awful long time !
Voyageur’s Wolf Project has been acting like they are a favorite food source !
It’s a lazy man who can’t find his wife a second job !
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363256
03/12/25 10:44 PM
03/12/25 10:44 PM
|
Joined: May 2010
MN
Steven 49er
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: May 2010
MN
|
Calvin, the northeast is not where the bulk of the population live.
Some will roam out?
You are talking like a 612er
"Gold is money, everything else is just credit" JP Morgan
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363478
03/13/25 10:14 AM
03/13/25 10:14 AM
|
Joined: Sep 2007
South metro, MN
Calvin
OP
trapper
|
OP
trapper
Joined: Sep 2007
South metro, MN
|
I was hoping you would chime in, Mike Kelly. I appreciate your input. Makes perfect sense to me.
The change in nuisance beaver removal is a good one. Back to what it was...and should have stayed, IMO. A good change back, nonetheless.
Steven, I am even south of 612 and admittedly don't live in wolf country. I get up to the Northeast section a couple times a year is all. This is why I'm asking questions. If there is a discrepancy in my, admitted, lack of wolf range knowledge, just clear it up. Everything doesn't have to be a pushing match.
Where is the bulk of the wolf population if not the northeast? From what I could find, wolves started there and has expanded outward as populations grew? Been a few wolves down this way here and there, even that apparently roamed out of their normal range. It's an honest question, that I'd actually like to know the answer to.
Last edited by Calvin; 03/13/25 10:40 AM.
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Mike Kelly]
#8363484
03/13/25 10:24 AM
03/13/25 10:24 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2007
MN
160user
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Jan 2007
MN
|
My list of reasons brought up would be in the following order…
#1. Drought. - We’ve been in a drought since 2021 now. Lots of ponds I have trapped beavers in are now dry. A lot either have dug channels or have totally been abandoned. These water levels for the most part are not controlled by beaver dams, but ponds that rely on rainfall and the water table to keep them full. #2. Trapping pressure - With a good market, and a couple easy winters and long fall/springs to trap. #3. Predators - Like others I think bears are just as much a preparator as Wolves. With a couple years of droughts the beavers are easier to target, and there are not as many other food sources through the summer for them. #4. Nuisance harvest - Its a factor, but for the most part pretty localized. The rule did change to make this not require a permit for most situations now.
I agree with you Mike. I took advantage of the cool morning when I could stay on top of the little snow and ice that remains in the woods. The ponds, swamps and creeks are DRY. I checked 3 ponds this morning that have had beaver for the last 15-20 years and none have beaver this winter. The runs into the houses are above the ice. I saw lots of deer and deer tracks as well as wolves turkey and grouse. There is plenty of food for the wolves here locally. I blame the beaver decline on the drought more than anything.
I have nothing clever to put here.
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363524
03/13/25 11:26 AM
03/13/25 11:26 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2006
MN, Land of 10,000 Lakes
Trapper7
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Dec 2006
MN, Land of 10,000 Lakes
|
Skilled Beaver trappers took far more Beaver than wolves in a much shorter period of time !
I think this "used to be" the case. I'm wondering if this still holds true today from what guys are actually seeing . Especially in the thick of wolf country where there are far more hungry wolves than hungry trappers today. Do 4,000 (or whatever we believe the numbers are) wolves (who hunt daily) take more beaver than a handful of aging trappers do, who trap when they feel like it? Most beaver trappers are aging and slowing down, let alone there's not much financial incentive to it anymore. Especially if they cant drive up to the site. Wolves on the other hand, are low on availability of food supplies nowadays. It "seems" like the wolves have figured out how to hunt and kill beaver more effectively nowadays out of pure necessity to survive. Just wondering what guys are really seeing out there. I know of one (north of Grand Marais) beaver trapper that seeing a big shift since the deer populations have tanked. That Elk releasing might be an interesting one to watch Trapper7. I wonder how many are going to come down with a (reported) mysterious illness when they get gobbled up. I went to a meeting in Little Falls about 25 years ago sponsored by the DNR. It was in regards to the expanding wolf population. At that time the DNR maintained the population of wolves in MN to be about 3300. Since then there has been what, 2 seasons on wolves with a limited quota which was met both times in short order. Today the DNR claims there are around 3,000 wolves statewide! The wolf has no real natural predators, no season on them in years, yet we are supposed to believe there are less wolves now than there was 25 years ago? There's only two answers regarding the DNR's numbers. Either they are lying or they're stupid. A guy representing a group called Hunters for Hunters was at one of our sportsmen's meetings. He claimed a more accurate number of wolves in MN would be around 10,000.
My wife wants me to wear a bracelet that belonged to her grandfather. It says, "Do Not Resuscitate".
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Mike Kelly]
#8363539
03/13/25 11:55 AM
03/13/25 11:55 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2006
Barnum, MN
ScottW
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Dec 2006
Barnum, MN
|
My list of reasons brought up would be in the following order…
#1. Drought. - We’ve been in a drought since 2021 now. Lots of ponds I have trapped beavers in are now dry. A lot either have dug channels or have totally been abandoned. These water levels for the most part are not controlled by beaver dams, but ponds that rely on rainfall and the water table to keep them full. #2. Trapping pressure - With a good market, and a couple easy winters and long fall/springs to trap. #3. Predators - Like others I think bears are just as much a preparator as Wolves. With a couple years of droughts the beavers are easier to target, and there are not as many other food sources through the summer for them. #4. Nuisance harvest - Its a factor, but for the most part pretty localized. The rule did change to make this not require a permit for most situations now.
Glad you took the time to type almost exactly what I was going to do I can just say I agree completely! :-). The drought is the biggest one no doubt as it even further enhances the predator successes. Happy trapping! ScottW
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: Calvin]
#8363548
03/13/25 12:06 PM
03/13/25 12:06 PM
|
Joined: Aug 2011
Northern MN
atrapper
trapper
|
trapper
Joined: Aug 2011
Northern MN
|
I agree with what most have said in regards to the most impactful variable for beaver populations being drought. I'm up on the Canadian border near Lake of the Woods. It's been very dry here, trapping pressure hasn't been terrible the last couple of years even with a better beaver market. There are plenty of predators around but anecdotally anyhow, I've lost more trapped beavers to bears than wolves. I've also caught wolves in dam crossovers that I assumed were there snooping around for caught beavers. But in general, bears eat more beavers than wolves.
Some food for thought.......a quick online search claimed wolves consume 3-4# of protein per day. 4#x365 days/year = 1,460# meat consumed per year for each wolf. Can we assume an overall average of one deer (likely more fawns than adult deer) will yield 50# of meat for a wolf? This would average out to be approximately 30 deer consumed per wolf each year. With an estimated wolf population of 3,000, that would mean wolves consume approximately 90,000 deer state wide per year. With an estimated wolf population of 10,000, that would put the number of deer consumed by wolves in one year at 300,000. The DNR estimates the current MN deer population at just a touch under 1 million. Hunters harvested just under 200,000 deer in 2024. Of course there are variables to consider such as a wolf's diet coming from proteins other than deer. Anyhow, just some quick and hard numbers but something to think about when hearing "estimated" and "probably" wolf population numbers. The truth is likely somewhere in between the DNR's estimation and a citizens claimed wolf population estimate.
|
|
|
Re: Wolf Range, MN beaver trappers
[Re: atrapper]
#8363655
03/13/25 02:14 PM
03/13/25 02:14 PM
|
Joined: Sep 2007
South metro, MN
Calvin
OP
trapper
|
OP
trapper
Joined: Sep 2007
South metro, MN
|
I agree with what most have said in regards to the most impactful variable for beaver populations being drought. I'm up on the Canadian border near Lake of the Woods. It's been very dry here, trapping pressure hasn't been terrible the last couple of years even with a better beaver market. There are plenty of predators around but anecdotally anyhow, I've lost more trapped beavers to bears than wolves. I've also caught wolves in dam crossovers that I assumed were there snooping around for caught beavers. But in general, bears eat more beavers than wolves.
Some food for thought.......a quick online search claimed wolves consume 3-4# of protein per day. 4#x365 days/year = 1,460# meat consumed per year for each wolf. Can we assume an overall average of one deer (likely more fawns than adult deer) will yield 50# of meat for a wolf? This would average out to be approximately 30 deer consumed per wolf each year. With an estimated wolf population of 3,000, that would mean wolves consume approximately 90,000 deer state wide per year. With an estimated wolf population of 10,000, that would put the number of deer consumed by wolves in one year at 300,000. The DNR estimates the current MN deer population at just a touch under 1 million. Hunters harvested just under 200,000 deer in 2024. Of course there are variables to consider such as a wolf's diet coming from proteins other than deer. Anyhow, just some quick and hard numbers but something to think about when hearing "estimated" and "probably" wolf population numbers. The truth is likely somewhere in between the DNR's estimation and a citizens claimed wolf population estimate. Been probably 20 years ago now but back then I spoke with one of the Mn DNR's main wolf biologists. I asked him how many deer he thought wolves killed each year. He estimated 22-25 deer per wolf per year. I'm sure most are fawns like you say. Of course as years went on, deer numbers decreased so I'm not sure what the number is today. But they probably haven't switched over to eating corn. Trapper 7: I know a couple that used to raise wolves in a big pen (until PETA with some liberal judges help shut them down). I used to bring them carcasses for feed. They said most people don't realize it but wolves kill their own all the time. They were always saving younger/subordinate wolves from being torn apart. They had a separate pen for these animals. So we know (at least pen raised wolves) kill they own. Of course the USDA kills just under 300 wolves per year here, too (well the "reported" numbers anyhow).
Last edited by Calvin; 03/13/25 02:15 PM.
|
|
|
|
|