| 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Husky]
 #8400691
 05/09/25 01:01 PM
05/09/25 01:01 PM
 | 
 
Joined:  Mar 2007
 McGrath,  AK
white17
 
 
  
"General (Mr.Sunshine) Washington"
 | 
 
  
 
  
"General (Mr.Sunshine) Washington" 
 
Joined:  Mar 2007 
McGrath,  AK
 | 
I  am  willing to  make  a  couple   suggestions to you  Husky.   First....pay attention  to  what  Waggler  is  trying  to  tell  you.    Remember  what  F.Scott Fitzgerald  said....“The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function" Next.........in  reference  to  your  belief  in a  6000  year  old   Earth,  and  universe........ There  are  currently, live  trees  in   Sweden that date to over  8000  years  old   and  one  of  them  dates  to  over  9500  years.   Derived  by  C14  dating  of  the  live  roots.   C14  is  quite  accurate  back to  about  20,000  years. Beyond  that  and  you  need  to  switch  systems..........but  C14  has  an  accuracy  of  50-100  years.  Essentially  nothing   when  dealing   with   ages  you  are talking  about. Also, very  near  your location  is an  archeological dig   that has  unearthed  and  identified....a  molar and  skull  fragments  of  a  three  year  old child  that  dates   back  to  about  11000  years  ago. The  child   was  buried  in a  fire pit in an  underground  shelter...  which were  common in Alaska  at  that  time.  The  associated  charcoal remains  in  the fire  pit  are a perfect substances   for  C14  dating, as  are the   bone fragments. You  can  see  these  exhibits  at  the    UAF  museum  in  Fairbanks. Give  some  thought  to  how  it  is  possible  for the  Earth, our  solar  system and  the   universe  to  be  all  the  same age..roughly.   Even  within our  own  solar system  there  are a  few objects  that are three  times   the  age  of  the  sun  and  our  planets.   And  in  the  remainder of  the  universe  there  are  billions   more  of  similar  antiquity.  I doubt  you  will  believe  any  of  that   so   here  are  a  couple  more   sincere   suggestions. Go  visit  Yellowstone Park.  Pay  attention  to  the   geology  and  maybe  even  talk  to  a  ranger  there if  there  is   one  that is  knowledgeable  on  the   subject.   You  will   find that   the  current iteration  of  Yellowstone   is  the  creation  of  a volcanic  eruption 640,000  years  ago.  This  can  be  dated   by  the  local  geology there. Especially  a  feature  known as  the  Obsidian Cliffs.   These  are far  too old  to be  dated  by  C14  method.  In this  case  scientists  have  used   the  decay  of  potassium  40...K40   into  its  daughter  element  Argon 40..AR40.    AR40 is  a "noble"  element.   It  does  not  decay   further.  It  is  stable.    Since   we  can  measure  the  ratio  in  the  existing  rock  of  K40   to  AR40.......and  we  know  the   rate  of  decay  of   K40........we  can  calculate  the  age  of  the   original   rock formation  event.   This   eruption   is   only  the   latest  one  at  Yellowstone.  There  have  been at  least  two  others that  were  much  larger  and  much  earlier.    We  can  still  see   much  earlier  evidence of  those  events   in  a  line  that  stretches southwest   from Yellowstone ....across  Idaho to  the    Oregon  border.   We  can  see a  similar thing  in  the  Hawaiian  Islands.   Those  islands  were  all  formed  the  same  way  at roughly  the  same  spot.   Due  to  plate tectonics  those  earlier  islands    are  moving   toward  Asia until  the  oldest   disappear  beneath  the   surface  as  the  Emperor Sea  Mounts......plunging  into  the  Aleutian  Trench   So,   since  you   are  just  15,  rather  than  suggest  a  college   course  in  geology   I  am  going  to  suggest  two  excellent  DVD  series that  you  can   very likely get  at a library   near  you. This  one  is  a  decent   introduction to the  geology in  general.     The  Prof  that   gives  these  lectures   is  very  open  to   questions  and  will  answer  you     as  time  permits.   You can  email  him https://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/the-world-s-greatest-geological-wonders-36-spectacular-siteshttps://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/cosmology-the-history-and-nature-of-our-universeThis  one  will challenge  you  in  a  lot  of  ways.   I  suspect  you  will disbelieve  a  lot  of  it  and   some  of  it  will seem  like  the   prof  is  speaking  a  foreign  language.   I  would  encourage  you to  watch the  whole  thing. I think  there  are  36  lectures.   Ignore  the  math  if  it  gets   confusing.   The  concepts  of  what  we know  and  how  we  know  it  are  more  important than the  math  that  proves  it. Last thing.   Is  a  book.     African  Genesis  by  Robert Ardrey.   Ardrey   was  educated   as  a  zoologist  but   spent most  of his  life  as  a  playwright.   Consequently,   the   book  is  easy  to read  and   I  found  it  to reveal   some  amazing  insights to the   real  world   of  nature  and  our  place  in  it.   The  book is  out of  print  but  I'm  sure  most any  library  will  have it..or  a  used  bookstore in   Fairbanks  
 
  
Mean As Nails
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: white17]
 #8400723
 05/09/25 02:09 PM
05/09/25 02:09 PM
 | 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006
 Coldspring Texas
Savell
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006 
Coldspring Texas
 | 
I  am  willing to  make  a  couple   suggestions to you  Husky.   First....pay attention  to  what  Waggler  is  trying  to  tell  you.    Remember  what  F.Scott Fitzgerald  said....“The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function" Next.........in  reference  to  your  belief  in a  6000  year  old   Earth,  and  universe........ There  are  currently, live  trees  in   Sweden that date to over  8000  years  old   and  one  of  them  dates  to  over  9500  years.   Derived  by  C14  dating  of  the  live  roots.   C14  is  quite  accurate  back to  about  20,000  years. Beyond  that  and  you  need  to  switch  systems..........but  C14  has  an  accuracy  of  50-100  years.  Essentially  nothing   when  dealing   with   ages  you  are talking  about. Also, very  near  your location  is an  archeological dig   that has  unearthed  and  identified....a  molar and  skull  fragments  of  a  three  year  old child  that  dates   back  to  about  11000  years  ago. The  child   was  buried  in a  fire pit in an  underground  shelter...  which were  common in Alaska  at  that  time.  The  associated  charcoal remains  in  the fire  pit  are a perfect substances   for  C14  dating, as  are the   bone fragments. You  can  see  these  exhibits  at  the    UAF  museum  in  Fairbanks. Give  some  thought  to  how  it  is  possible  for the  Earth, our  solar  system and  the   universe  to  be  all  the  same age..roughly.   Even  within our  own  solar system  there  are a  few objects  that are three  times   the  age  of  the  sun  and  our  planets.   And  in  the  remainder of  the  universe  there  are  billions   more  of  similar  antiquity.  I doubt  you  will  believe  any  of  that   so   here  are  a  couple  more   sincere   suggestions. Go  visit  Yellowstone Park.  Pay  attention  to  the   geology  and  maybe  even  talk  to  a  ranger  there if  there  is   one  that is  knowledgeable  on  the   subject.   You  will   find that   the  current iteration  of  Yellowstone   is  the  creation  of  a volcanic  eruption 640,000  years  ago.  This  can  be  dated   by  the  local  geology there. Especially  a  feature  known as  the  Obsidian Cliffs.   These  are far  too old  to be  dated  by  C14  method.  In this  case  scientists  have  used   the  decay  of  potassium  40...K40   into  its  daughter  element  Argon 40..AR40.    AR40 is  a "noble"  element.   It  does  not  decay   further.  It  is  stable.    Since   we  can  measure  the  ratio  in  the  existing  rock  of  K40   to  AR40.......and  we  know  the   rate  of  decay  of   K40........we  can  calculate  the  age  of  the   original   rock formation  event.   This   eruption   is   only  the   latest  one  at  Yellowstone.  There  have  been at  least  two  others that  were  much  larger  and  much  earlier.    We  can  still  see   much  earlier  evidence of  those  events   in  a  line  that  stretches southwest   from Yellowstone ....across  Idaho to  the    Oregon  border.   We  can  see a  similar thing  in  the  Hawaiian  Islands.   Those  islands  were  all  formed  the  same  way  at roughly  the  same  spot.   Due  to  plate tectonics  those  earlier  islands    are  moving   toward  Asia until  the  oldest   disappear  beneath  the   surface  as  the  Emperor Sea  Mounts......plunging  into  the  Aleutian  Trench   So,   since  you   are  just  15,  rather  than  suggest  a  college   course  in  geology   I  am  going  to  suggest  two  excellent  DVD  series that  you  can   very likely get  at a library   near  you. This  one  is  a  decent   introduction to the  geology in  general.     The  Prof  that   gives  these  lectures   is  very  open  to   questions  and  will  answer  you     as  time  permits.   You can  email  him https://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/the-world-s-greatest-geological-wonders-36-spectacular-siteshttps://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/cosmology-the-history-and-nature-of-our-universeThis  one  will challenge  you  in  a  lot  of  ways.   I  suspect  you  will disbelieve  a  lot  of  it  and   some  of  it  will seem  like  the   prof  is  speaking  a  foreign  language.   I  would  encourage  you to  watch the  whole  thing. I think  there  are  36  lectures.   Ignore  the  math  if  it  gets   confusing.   The  concepts  of  what  we know  and  how  we  know  it  are  more  important than the  math  that  proves  it. Last thing.   Is  a  book.     African  Genesis  by  Robert Ardrey.   Ardrey   was  educated   as  a  zoologist  but   spent most  of his  life  as  a  playwright.   Consequently,   the   book  is  easy  to read  and   I  found  it  to reveal   some  amazing  insights to the   real  world   of  nature  and  our  place  in  it.   The  book is  out of  print  but  I'm  sure  most any  library  will  have it..or  a  used  bookstore in   Fairbanks .. that’s what I was going to say lol  
 
  
Insert profound nonsense here 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Husky]
 #8400829
 05/09/25 05:08 PM
05/09/25 05:08 PM
 | 
 
Joined:  Oct 2013
 East of the Mason-Dixon Line 
DelawareRob
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Oct 2013 
East of the Mason-Dixon Line 
 | 
How big would the ark have been if it actually had that many animals on it.  I mean, there would have to be evolution. Right? I forget the total numbers, but it would be more than could fit on that boat. 
 
  
Stop over cooking your meat! It isn’t gamey, it’s over cooked! 
  Gordon Ramsey, maybe…
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Husky]
 #8400867
 05/09/25 06:00 PM
05/09/25 06:00 PM
 | 
 
Joined:  Oct 2013
 East of the Mason-Dixon Line 
DelawareRob
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Oct 2013 
East of the Mason-Dixon Line 
 | 
There was two of every kind in the Ark. Which could mean two dogs that would have all the genetic material for every species of dog in the world. It would also seem logical to have the animals in the ark be babies instead of full grown adults. That was just the unclean animals. He took 7 pairs each of the clean one.   ![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2025/05/full-35779-257391-img_9224.jpeg) But, how long for all those “kinds” to evolve into each species.  And it was pretty clear it was a lot of different kinds.    ![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2025/05/full-35779-257392-img_9225.jpeg) And even if they were babies, that’s a lot of room. But, I guess if it’s going to be done, it would have to be God that makes it possible, because physics and math sure isn’t going to make it work.   And what would it have started at?  The domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family or genus?  And which is the “kind”?   
 
  
Stop over cooking your meat! It isn’t gamey, it’s over cooked! 
  Gordon Ramsey, maybe…
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Husky]
 #8401090
 05/10/25 01:57 AM
05/10/25 01:57 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  May 2016
 Southern Illinois
Foxpaw
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  May 2016 
Southern Illinois
 | 
The kind is pretty easy to explain. A wolf and a dingo, same kind. Wolf and a lion, not the same kind. Think of dogs, cats, lizards, and snakes as their own kinds.
  My guess it would have started at Order. At the risk of promoting a new  breed of philosopher by not rejecting foolish and ignorant speculation, and for the reason we know that it breeds quarreling by not refusing foolish and ignorant questionings, knowing that they generate strife. With that in mind I ask: Can you prove the house cat even exists by using only the bible? And what breed of dog could it have possibly been that was with Tobiah on his trip in the Book of Tobit?  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: white17]
 #8401091
 05/10/25 02:26 AM
05/10/25 02:26 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Jul 2024
 IL
NorthwesternYote
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Jul 2024 
IL
 | 
I  am  willing to  make  a  couple   suggestions to you  Husky.   First....pay attention  to  what  Waggler  is  trying  to  tell  you.    Remember  what  F.Scott Fitzgerald  said....“The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function" Next.........in  reference  to  your  belief  in a  6000  year  old   Earth,  and  universe........ There  are  currently, live  trees  in   Sweden that date to over  8000  years  old   and  one  of  them  dates  to  over  9500  years.   Derived  by  C14  dating  of  the  live  roots.   C14  is  quite  accurate  back to  about  20,000  years. Beyond  that  and  you  need  to  switch  systems..........but  C14  has  an  accuracy  of  50-100  years.  Essentially  nothing   when  dealing   with   ages  you  are talking  about. Also, very  near  your location  is an  archeological dig   that has  unearthed  and  identified....a  molar and  skull  fragments  of  a  three  year  old child  that  dates   back  to  about  11000  years  ago. The  child   was  buried  in a  fire pit in an  underground  shelter...  which were  common in Alaska  at  that  time.  The  associated  charcoal remains  in  the fire  pit  are a perfect substances   for  C14  dating, as  are the   bone fragments. You  can  see  these  exhibits  at  the    UAF  museum  in  Fairbanks. Give  some  thought  to  how  it  is  possible  for the  Earth, our  solar  system and  the   universe  to  be  all  the  same age..roughly.   Even  within our  own  solar system  there  are a  few objects  that are three  times   the  age  of  the  sun  and  our  planets.   And  in  the  remainder of  the  universe  there  are  billions   more  of  similar  antiquity.  I doubt  you  will  believe  any  of  that   so   here  are  a  couple  more   sincere   suggestions. Go  visit  Yellowstone Park.  Pay  attention  to  the   geology  and  maybe  even  talk  to  a  ranger  there if  there  is   one  that is  knowledgeable  on  the   subject.   You  will   find that   the  current iteration  of  Yellowstone   is  the  creation  of  a volcanic  eruption 640,000  years  ago.  This  can  be  dated   by  the  local  geology there. Especially  a  feature  known as  the  Obsidian Cliffs.   These  are far  too old  to be  dated  by  C14  method.  In this  case  scientists  have  used   the  decay  of  potassium  40...K40   into  its  daughter  element  Argon 40..AR40.    AR40 is  a "noble"  element.   It  does  not  decay   further.  It  is  stable.    Since   we  can  measure  the  ratio  in  the  existing  rock  of  K40   to  AR40.......and  we  know  the   rate  of  decay  of   K40........we  can  calculate  the  age  of  the   original   rock formation  event.   This   eruption   is   only  the   latest  one  at  Yellowstone.  There  have  been at  least  two  others that  were  much  larger  and  much  earlier.    We  can  still  see   much  earlier  evidence of  those  events   in  a  line  that  stretches southwest   from Yellowstone ....across  Idaho to  the    Oregon  border.   We  can  see a  similar thing  in  the  Hawaiian  Islands.   Those  islands  were  all  formed  the  same  way  at roughly  the  same  spot.   Due  to  plate tectonics  those  earlier  islands    are  moving   toward  Asia until  the  oldest   disappear  beneath  the   surface  as  the  Emperor Sea  Mounts......plunging  into  the  Aleutian  Trench   So,   since  you   are  just  15,  rather  than  suggest  a  college   course  in  geology   I  am  going  to  suggest  two  excellent  DVD  series that  you  can   very likely get  at a library   near  you. This  one  is  a  decent   introduction to the  geology in  general.     The  Prof  that   gives  these  lectures   is  very  open  to   questions  and  will  answer  you     as  time  permits.   You can  email  him https://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/the-world-s-greatest-geological-wonders-36-spectacular-siteshttps://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/cosmology-the-history-and-nature-of-our-universeThis  one  will challenge  you  in  a  lot  of  ways.   I  suspect  you  will disbelieve  a  lot  of  it  and   some  of  it  will seem  like  the   prof  is  speaking  a  foreign  language.   I  would  encourage  you to  watch the  whole  thing. I think  there  are  36  lectures.   Ignore  the  math  if  it  gets   confusing.   The  concepts  of  what  we know  and  how  we  know  it  are  more  important than the  math  that  proves  it. Last thing.   Is  a  book.     African  Genesis  by  Robert Ardrey.   Ardrey   was  educated   as  a  zoologist  but   spent most  of his  life  as  a  playwright.   Consequently,   the   book  is  easy  to read  and   I  found  it  to reveal   some  amazing  insights to the   real  world   of  nature  and  our  place  in  it.   The  book is  out of  print  but  I'm  sure  most any  library  will  have it..or  a  used  bookstore in   Fairbanks All we have to do is look up into the night sky and see the stars that are millions of light years away.  If the universe were created 6000 years ago, the light from those stars wouldn't have had enough time to reach us yet and we wouldn't be able to see them.  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Foxpaw]
 #8401102
 05/10/25 03:01 AM
05/10/25 03:01 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Dec 2024
 North Pole, Alaska
Husky
 
OP 
trapper
 | 
 
  
OP 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Dec 2024 
North Pole, Alaska
 | 
The kind is pretty easy to explain. A wolf and a dingo, same kind. Wolf and a lion, not the same kind. Think of dogs, cats, lizards, and snakes as their own kinds.
  My guess it would have started at Order. At the risk of promoting a new  breed of philosopher by not rejecting foolish and ignorant speculation, and for the reason we know that it breeds quarreling by not refusing foolish and ignorant questionings, knowing that they generate strife. With that in mind I ask: Can you prove the house cat even exists by using only the bible? And what breed of dog could it have possibly been that was with Tobiah on his trip in the Book of Tobit? What do you mean can I prove the house cat exists only using the Bible? And what is the Book of Tobit??  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: KeithC]
 #8401106
 05/10/25 03:05 AM
05/10/25 03:05 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Dec 2024
 North Pole, Alaska
Husky
 
OP 
trapper
 | 
 
  
OP 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Dec 2024 
North Pole, Alaska
 | 
I don't think anyone of normal intelligence would believe the entire myth of Noah, unless they were taught it as the truth as a child, especially if their first exposure to the myth was after age 25. 
  Keith What about the Flood do you not understand?  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Husky]
 #8401119
 05/10/25 03:43 AM
05/10/25 03:43 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Jul 2024
 IL
NorthwesternYote
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Jul 2024 
IL
 | 
There are so many things that I or nobody else can fully comprehend about God. An all powerful God like Him would obviously be powerful enough to bring the light to the earth regardless of how far it was. After all, he was the creator of light. I have no doubt that He is powerful enough, but I don't know why he would go through all the trouble to bring the light from those stars to earth and mess with the rate of radioactive decay to mess up our radiocarbon dating measurements.  Why would he do all these things to throw off our observations and scientific instruments?  He gave man the intellect and curiosity to learn about and study His creation; He wants us to do this.  So why would he troll us with false measurements? The Bible was written by people.  The authors were inspired by God but they were not writing a science book.  The stories in Genesis, in particular, shouldn't be read as literal histories of the world, but we should seek to understand the lessons those stories convey.  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Husky]
 #8401129
 05/10/25 04:43 AM
05/10/25 04:43 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Jul 2024
 IL
NorthwesternYote
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Jul 2024 
IL
 | 
Every single statement the Bible makes is true and has been proven true. If you are saying the Genesis account of Creation is wrong than you are saying the entire Bible is wrong too. Like I said earlier, find one lie or false statement in the Bible. Just so you know, you’re going to have some trouble finding one. There are TWO stories of creation in Genesis. In the first story of creation, God creates the land animals before He creates man.  Genesis 1:25-27 In the second story of creation, God creates man first and then He creates the animals and brings them before the man to name them.  Genesis 2:19-20 They can't both be the literal truth; they contradict each other.  So which one is false?  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Debate
[Re: Husky]
 #8401142
 05/10/25 05:16 AM
05/10/25 05:16 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006
 williamsburg ks
danny clifton
 
 
"Grumpy Old Man"
 | 
 
  
 
"Grumpy Old Man" 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006 
williamsburg ks
 | 
Husky, not accepting biblical stories as truth does not mean accepting evolution and big bang as truth. The bible is full of wisdom and science has been able to unravel a lot of mysteries. There are things we just dont have answers for. Being human and curious we keep looking though. 
 
  
Those who would give up essential liberty, to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790)
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
 
 |  
 
 |