![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2025/08/full-1790-267192-1000021071.jpg)
When their bodies were discovered hanging from a rough tree scaffold, Ella Watson and James Averell had already become symbols of something darker than frontier justice. The scene was haunting—two figures side by side, arms almost touching, cowboy lariats tied tightly around their necks. Their faces were swollen and distorted, tongues protruding in death’s final indignity. A local reporter described it with unflinching clarity, but behind the brutality lay a deeper injustice: a murder orchestrated not by outlaws, but by powerful cattlemen determined to wipe out competition.
Ella Watson—known to many as "Cattle Kate"—was no outlaw. Born Ellen Liddy Watson, she was a hardworking homesteader trying to claim a piece of the Wyoming frontier at a time when the open range was controlled by ruthless cattle barons. She and James Averell, a fellow settler and her partner in both land and life, had started to build a modest ranch. That progress, however, provoked the ire of the Wyoming Stock Growers Association—a powerful group that saw independent ranchers as threats. On the flimsiest accusation of cattle rustling—a charge never convincingly proven—Ella and Jim were lynched without trial on July 20, 1889.
Their deaths stirred whispers but brought little justice. No one was ever convicted, and the influential men behind the lynching escaped consequences. Yet, over time, history began to favor Ella. As the myth of “Cattle Kate the rustler” faded, the truth of Ella Watson the murdered homesteader emerged. Her story became a symbol of the lawless greed that sometimes wore a badge or wielded a ranch brand. Today, she is remembered not as a thief, but as a woman caught in the crossfire of a ruthless land war—her story echoing as a reminder of how the West was truly won.
