True, whether we are talking moose or elk it is amazing the difference in the amount of meat between a young bull and a mature one. I guide elk and so I generally pack out quite a few, as well as my own. There have been a few times when I was really wishing it was a smaller bull shot by the time I got it out. But it is nice to have that extra meat in the freezer.
when you say you pack out elk, what does that mean? I see many western state do not require all the edible meat to be salvaged or packed out.
I mean packing it out on my back (packboard). Depends on state and what is considered edible. Here in Idaho the regs state that you must pack out all edible meat (deer, elk, moose, antelope, sheep, goat. You are not required to salvage meat of bear, cougar or wolf) of big game. Not including rib meat, or meat on the legs below the knee, meat of the head or neck, internal organs or meat on the bones after close trimming.
Generally I take the quarters with leg bones (knocked off at the knee unless the client wants the hooves, and yes I've had more than one want them to make a lamp or something out of) and remove the backstraps, tenderloins, and neck meat. Leaving the spine, ribcage, and pelvis in the woods. If I am doing it for myself the liver, etc. is left in the gutpile with the rest of the guts, I will pack out the liver and heart though if the client wants it. So no I don't pack out the heavy bones or hide, but I do pack out all of the meat with the exception of that between the ribs. Personally I don't eat the neck meat off a rutting bull, and generally warn a client to keep it separate from the rest of their burger meat, but it does get packed out unless it was neck shot and is full of bone fragments.
Generally salvage meat from bear and cougar also, even though not required. I won't eat a bear that has been eating rotten stuff however, so it is nice to not be required to salvage meat I'm not going to eat. A lot of our clients don't want the meat off bear or cougar, but there is usually somebody local who will be happy to take it.