Copy/paste
Open borders + state welfare = disaster
These two things cannot coexist within a society without destroying it.
When millions of low-skill workers flood a labor market simultaneously, wages at the bottom compress. Supply and demand operate exactly as advertised. George Borjas ran the numbers on the 1980 Mariel boatlift: 125,000 Cubans hit Miami in under six months, and wages for native high school dropouts fell measurably. The market eventually adjusts, but "eventually" is cold comfort when your paycheck shrinks this quarter.
The fiscal damage compounds separately from the wage effect. A low-income household in California consumes roughly $30,000 annually in state and federal services, schooling, healthcare, and transfer payments, while paying perhaps $4,000 in taxes. Multiply that gap across millions of arrivals and you have a structural deficit that your children inherit as debt.
Welfare states and open borders cannot coexist indefinitely. The tax-funded magnet subsidizes arrival and rewards dependency. Destroy the welfare state, and mass migration becomes a straightforward story of voluntary exchange, workers seeking employers, capital seeking labor. Keep the welfare state and open the gates, and you are simply voting to transfer wealth from working taxpayers to a federal distribution apparatus.
The hard question is never "should people move freely?" It is who owns the tab when they arrive.