I thought the Supremes made a" the legislative law does not allow for an administrative ban" not that" the second amendment prevents the legislature from banning the ownership of bump stocks" ? Not really a second amendment ruling?

That's the way I understand it too. The statutes (1934 NFA and 1986 GCA) define a machine gun. BATFE passed a rule which they had no statutory authority to make.

I believe it is analogous to the recent WV v EPA decision where SCOTUS ruled EPA did not have the authority to make the rule it was trying to enforce.

This is, IMO, a good start at reining in the illegal rule making of the alphabet agencies

Very True you can add the anti-abortion "law" which returned the discretion back to the states for a vote instead of federal oversite Unless you got your facts from fbook or other "expert" resources

Hobbie, you said more than a mouthful on that one. THAT is EXACTLY why they had the second Amendment to begin with!!!

Never heard one from you either on your lies and BS!!!

I'd rather have Don Jr. advising his father on the 2nd Amendment than Biden's kid advising his father. Trump has learned who his friends are.

Don't let this get political. Also, no petty personal crap !

This case was not a direct challenge to the NFA or GCA and the court limited itself to only the question at hand. Whether the BATFE had the authority to enact rule making absent legislative authority.

It's going to take a direct challenge to NFA/GCA using the Bruen decision to build on. Meanwhile until that case comes along we are winning these cases on the margins thanks to the Trump Trifecta.

Probably of more importance across the board is just what this ruling signals for the Chevron Deference standard. For those not in the know, Chevron Deference is the standard mandated by prior SCOTUS rulings that requires federal courts to defer to "expert opinion" of federal regulatory agencies when contemplating cases of this type.

Like the much needed challenge to NFA/GCA a case will come along that'll get Chevron Deference knocked down and maybe, just maybe, we can get the various alphabet agencies reined in on the ever growing regulatory burden.

I still believe that full auto was used in Vegas. Its such a simple thing to make the parts that give an AR a three position selector switch. The alphabet's dont want to admit that outlaws could care less about NFA. Was a guy arrested here some years back for making the parts, and a template for drilling the third hole and milling out the back of the receiver, on machines used in a shop that built cranes. The guy that shot those people was wealthy. Makes no sense he would use a toy like a bump stock. A binary trigger is more effective than a bump stock

For the mensa members who don’t believe politicians play 3d or 4d chess or whatever you want to call it, have any of you ever heard of daca?

Good grief!!!

The country is awash of illegal full auto firearms that the powers that be won't prosecute because of who owns them. Glock switches are ubiquitous in the cities and the D A 's won't touch those cases, they let them go without bail or charges. The genie is out of the bottle with 3d printers.

Wish sold most of those glock switches , the air soft trigger works very similar to the glock factory trigger so the air soft selector switch dropped right into an actual glock

he died any way , loading one of his two planes with every gas can he could and crashing it onto the audience would have done more.
lots didn't add up and we will likely never know