Our buck to doe ratio isn’t anywhere it needs to be…yet.
Yes this is a Wild Bird plantation and is managed as such. I “lucked up” getting on this place. The manager didn’t care about deer when I started, but has since unofficially put my son and I over the deer hunting aspect. His policy was 3 does per person and 1 buck that MUST be mounted.
It wasn’t until several years back that his youngest son wanted a nice buck. They went and sat in a stand and saw 34 does and 5 scrub bucks one morning. That’s when he wanted to know what to do to get decent bucks?
What he didnt realize was we had some really nice bucks that could spend all rut in a 10ac spot and breed as many does as his body would allow.
Our first recommendation was at minimum everyone shoot their limit of 10 does each. There’s only about 4-5 (full time) hunters with 3-4 others that’ll hunt some. We also told him we need to take older age bucks regardless of “score”. When you have 5.5 - 8.5 year old 8’s and below running off your 2.5 -4.5 year old 10’s and above that will score 130” by 2.5 then you have issues.
He agreed to all of it and told anyone if they didn’t know what a mature buck was to text my son and I. So far it’s working. I’m not an expert or educated on the matter, but I know what a mature deer looks like and we know what needs shot vs what doesn’t. Even the managers wife will text with pics asking yes or no.
We had a 172” killed in ‘21. A 168” killed in ‘22. Nothing over 160” last year, but we definitely have a few roaming the woods this year that should make it.
Now for the part that will upset a few folks, we will shoot the does. All meat finds a home. I take several with my bow just because and that’s hunting. After that it’s just pure killing. Laws are obeyed as much as possible, but when folks can’t get it done we’ll step in and help them. I know between my son and I we kill close to 50-60 a year.
And believe it or not we still have folks wanting deer at the end of season.
My son and I only archery hunt bucks now. I have no problem with anyone shooting whatever makes them happy and when we have youth out to hunt they are given free rein to shoot anything from spots to the State record. We’ve made a lot of young folks some great memories and hope to continue to do so.
In order to have bucks reach their full potential they have everything on this place including time. Yeah, it’s tough sometimes to pass some really great looking young bucks, but we’ve seen what can happen when you do. Yes it can be a gamble. This isn’t a high fenced property, just 2500 continuous acres. We talk with the surrounding hunters (my son started that) and we’ll talk about what we have on cameras and make a gentleman’s agreement of bucks we’d “like” to see the following year. Last year they killed a deer we’d agreed that was a trophy and they ended up killing him. He was high 160’s as well and we all honestly thought he wouldn’t get any larger antler wise. So far everything is working out pretty good. I will say, after I killed what I consider a true “trophy antlered” buck it changed me. I no longer think if I don’t kill a trophy my year is ruined. Nor do I get upset when someone else does. In fact, I found and put the stand up for the deer my DIL shot in the above video. I get happy with others success because I feel what we’ve done contributes to that success, so technically I’m a part of it.
Our only issue we’re running into now is the other hunters have seen what can be produced and they’re wanting to let everything go, lol. Hoping once everyone gets their cameras out we’ll start getting pics and text and get some of these older bucks killed.
Here’s a pic the managers wife sent of a young 10 and asked shooter?
![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2024/07/full-51940-224453-68998390907__8c5c8b5b_e36f_4281_b204_6958a1d3ee0e_original.jpeg)
My response was you’re the Bosslady you can shoot whatever, but no Ma’am he really needs another year.
She then sent this pic….
Immediately I sent “Send it, shoot!! Definitely a shooter!!”
She did…
That buck I know was at least 7.5 cause I had his pics for 4 years, lol. Believe it or not that deer scored either 141 or 142 and doesn’t have tine over 7”. Just an OLD buck that needed taken out and a true trophy!!