I've found that a size 10.5 is a size 10.5. Think about it. If you were going to make a size 10.5 shoe the first thing you would grab is the 10.5 mold and build the shoe around it. The steel toe included. They don't shave material away to make the steel toe fit the mold or then it wouldn't fit your foot. I wore red wings for the longest time but they switched to China. They need broke in. The pair I've worn the last couple of years are Carolinas. They were comfortable right out of the box and made in the USA. My red wings laced up with cleats all the way up. The Carolinas have an eyelet at the top. That eyelet really slows you down putting your shoes on in the morning I kinda hate fooling with it and my feet get screaming hot in the Carolinas and I didn't have that problem with the red wings. The airwalk safety shoes on amazon are comfy and are a true to size low top skate board sneaker. Twisted X makes a comfy safety toe thats half way fashionable looking, they wear like house slippers. Let me throw some pics up and thats my review of safety shoes everyday for the last 25 years at the ol factory. Anyway I'm a 10.5 narrow with an arch and wore a 10.5 in all of those.
I'm a new fan of the complete flat sole too without a heel. Thats what the steel workers always wore and I tried it and I think its the way to go. Good luck.
Rereading your orig post... I really liked that red wing had the thing that measure your feet and it was a red wing measurer sizing your feet for red wing shoes. So a EE redwing measure is for sure a EE red wing boot size for example. Go that route and buy the more expensive shoe insert upgrade at the redwing store while you are there. The serious guys change those inserts every six months. Anyway if you want what fits that's the way I would go. The trick is realizing all those measurements may be different at another store with however they measure their shoes.
I remember thinking my first pair of red wings feeling like they may have been the first pair of shoes that ever actually fit me right at age at 25 yo 23 years ago. All of these I suggested fit real well though.
If you go red wings make sure you oil them up and wear them in the evenings around the house for a couple weeks before heading to work in them and when you head to work make sure your old shoes are in the car.
p.s. I have safety toe doc martins in 10.5 and I can't wear them they pinch my pinky toe but thats what I get for buying doc martin work boots. So anyway, those run small but I think it was more how they cut the material and the edge poking my pinky toe than the fit. It was like there was a knot right in the wrong spot.
![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2025/05/full-24446-256649-red.jpg)
![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2025/05/full-24446-256650-carolina.jpg)
![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2025/05/full-24446-256651-twisted.jpg)