| 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Lugnut]
 #8459025
 08/23/25 10:07 AM
08/23/25 10:07 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020
 Indiana
Providence Farm
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020 
Indiana
 | 
I’m not debating that crossbows are an evil tool or for the lazy. 
  I have simply a bad taste in my mouth about them from someone we know who continually takes less than desirable, long shots and fails to recover MULTIPLE deer each season. I single-handedly blame this person for the existence of our antler restrictions. He’s a friend of the family but one of the lousiest examples of a fair chase hunter I’ve ever encountered. There are plenty of traditional archers that refuse to put in the practice time and/or wait for ethical shots that are crippling and killing deer they never recover. I know because I find dead deer with arrow wounds and arrows broken off in them all the time while hunting small game with my dogs. I see plenty of wounded deer limping around after archery season as well.  I really fail to see how one guy could cause statewide antler restrictions.     my boys asked me how many deer i killed when they were small.   told them i ha no idea.  Tried constant counting. Gave up after loosing track around 175  so figured between that and low 200's.  Point if that is i have shot  5 deer i didn't recover  out of close to 200. 4 were with my compound and the shots were the same about 5 to 10 yards  sharp down angle  .Nice but  battery blood trail  that vanished about 40 yards    Always rhout they died untill a guy at work described a shot he made on a buck he could not find. Described it to a T.  2 weeks later that buck was back on his trail cam with nicely heeling up hole in his back.  And he survived.  So maybe I dind find them becuse they lived        Point of that is 5 yards with compound  would be considered ethical.      Both my boys are at about 25 each now and neither have lost a single deer.  I have never killed a deer with x bow yet. but have been with my kids when they have shot several  and it seems like the deer go down faster shot with the x bow by kids than all mine shot with my compound.   infact   Not one has not gone down in sight.   This is with kids doing the shooting mind you . The tool has nothing to do with ethics.   Some people  would be fine deer hunting and dropping deer with a .22.  Others shoot them all the time and loose them wit 300 win mag.  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Donnersurvivor]
 #8459029
 08/23/25 10:09 AM
08/23/25 10:09 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020
 Indiana
Providence Farm
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020 
Indiana
 | 
Most of our state is a one deer limit with some areas being buck only due to low population, we didn't need more efficient means to take deer For 3 1/2 months. Going to end up with more efficient weapons and draw tags.  Could also be more accurate shoots being taken amd less lost deer.  One shot tag filled and  done for the year instead of guy shooting 4 becuse he lost the first 3.  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Pafoxman]
 #8459031
 08/23/25 10:13 AM
08/23/25 10:13 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006
 SEPA
Lugnut
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006 
SEPA
 | 
 Of course they hunted in the early season. If you reread my op I'm pretty sure I said I have no issue with older folks, anyone who can't pull lol l a bow due to physical limitations or KIDS using them. If some people on here had reasonable reading comprehension skills this thread would only be 3 pages lol If you'd learn how to use the quote feature your posts would be a lot more readable.  
 
  
Eh...wot?
  
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Pafoxman]
 #8459034
 08/23/25 10:19 AM
08/23/25 10:19 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Jan 2007
 MD
DaveP
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Jan 2007 
MD
 | 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Providence Farm]
 #8459036
 08/23/25 10:20 AM
08/23/25 10:20 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Jan 2017
 Marion Kansas
Yes sir
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Jan 2017 
Marion Kansas
 | 
Most of our state is a one deer limit with some areas being buck only due to low population, we didn't need more efficient means to take deer For 3 1/2 months. Going to end up with more efficient weapons and draw tags.  Could also be more accurate shoots being taken amd less lost deer.  One shot tag filled and  done for the year instead of guy shooting 4 becuse he lost the first 3.        This is a fact only thread..... let's refrain from the "could also be" hypothetical comments please  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Pafoxman]
 #8459037
 08/23/25 10:22 AM
08/23/25 10:22 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020
 Indiana
Providence Farm
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020 
Indiana
 | 
 Guess we should cut down bow season  and have a x bow, black powder, firearms,and air gun season only.   Only  one hunting tool type alowde during  that seasion.  No overtime lap. An bow being used for 3 months .  
   I mean who need 3 months to tag out after all.  300 + fps  bow  limit to 2 weekends a year.   makes  since  to me. 
   Or if the population is so low  maybe there should be no season at all tell the population recovers.  
Last edited by Providence Farm; 08/23/25 10:24 AM.
 
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: DaveP]
 #8459048
 08/23/25 10:48 AM
08/23/25 10:48 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020
 Indiana
Providence Farm
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Feb 2020 
Indiana
 | 
If you are gonna go traditional, go traditional!  ![[Linked Image]](https://trapperman.com/forum/attachments/usergals/2025/08/full-2625-267455-1000008123.png) Folks still making them that way today, no need to.use new fangled materials and cheat.       I always thought I would try that someday.    Just flat out  awesome, in my book  that and tanning and making clothing like k snow  are outstanding.      Buy the time im.willing to dededicat the time.to learn  i will be dead at this rate.  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Pafoxman]
 #8459057
 08/23/25 11:13 AM
08/23/25 11:13 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006
 Pa
Wright Brothers
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Dec 2006 
Pa
 | 
I was browsing used bows and saw a creed, quickly turned the channel lol. Over here only half the dead deer are owned by "hunters". The insurance co owns the other half. Mr Green jeans claim them for two weeks and farmers feed em full time. Trouble makers is all they are. Anybody got a xbow for sale     
 
  
 
  
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Providence Farm]
 #8459068
 08/23/25 11:34 AM
08/23/25 11:34 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Jan 2018
 MN
Donnersurvivor
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Jan 2018 
MN
 | 
 
   I mean who need 3 months to tag out after all.  300 + fps  bow  limit to 2 weekends a year.   makes  since  to me. 
   Or if the population is so low  maybe there should be no season at all tell the population recovers.  Or we could have a 4 month season and the guys who don't want to take a few mins a week to practice could find a new hobby  
 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Pafoxman]
 #8459071
 08/23/25 11:44 AM
08/23/25 11:44 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  May 2011
 Oakland, MS
yotetrapper30
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  May 2011 
Oakland, MS
 | 
There's an easy fix to this problem.  Eliminate archery season.  Just have "deer season".  Use a rifle, shotgun, flintlock, caplock, compound bow, longbow, crossbow, recurve bow, atlatl, axe handle.... any legal weapon of your choice.  Problem solved.   
Last edited by yotetrapper30; 08/23/25 11:45 AM. Reason: Edited to add axe handle to the list.
 
 
  
Proudly banned from the NTA.  
  Bother me tomorrow.  Today I'll buy no sorrows.
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: yotetrapper30]
 #8459073
 08/23/25 11:47 AM
08/23/25 11:47 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Feb 2010
 pa
hippie
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Feb 2010 
pa
 | 
There's an easy fix to this problem.  Eliminate archery season.  Just have "deer season".  Use a rifle, shotgun, flintlock, caplock, compound bow, longbow, crossbow, recurve bow, atlatl, axe handle.... any legal weapon of your choice.  Problem solved.   Yep, Gotta give bow hunters a couple of the best months to hunt and pick of the crop.  One month for everyone, choose your one and only one weapon and see how proud they are to bow hunt.  
 
  
There comes a point liberalism has gone too far, we're past that point.
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
Re: Who hates crossbows??
[Re: Pafoxman]
 #8459077
 08/23/25 11:52 AM
08/23/25 11:52 AM
 | 
 
Joined:  Jan 2007
 MD
DaveP
 
 
trapper
 | 
 
  
 
trapper 
 
Joined:  Jan 2007 
MD
 | 
 |  
 
 | 
 
 
 | 
 
 
 
 
 |  
 
 |