Glad it’s working for him! I’ve yet to see anyone do one of those “permaculture” gardens that can beat a conventional garden around here. But i think it is because everyone I know doing a “permaculture garden” has no idea what they are doing and just says permaculture to make up for not weeding or fertilizing their stuff. I’m real interested in all of the regenerative/permaculture planting styles
Yeah most people who do them don't really do them properly, like folks think there a push button for easy peasy and just think they can toss stuff together and it works....yeahhhhhh no . I mean this kid has mapped out the sun stages around the property, done soil samples , there is a decent bit of work to it ...just not in the same way as a regular garden .
It's like regular fishing Vs a trotline. Yeah trot lines look really easy and should just work...till you get billy joe trying it with a $20 kit from Walmart

might catch some but your not gonna be as good and fast as somone like Matt Jones who knows the ins and out of the fish water , hooks lines bait ect.... In that case might just wanna stick to the pole and line lol !
Then there's also the deal of things being apples to apples you know a 2acre trad garden will probably out produce a 1/4 acre permaculture one just due to...well volume.
Don't help my brother does stuff that is like a completely foreign concept to many around here . Like compost, no one round here composts . When we would push up the leftovers from the hay bales in a big pile in the pasture eveyone was beyond confused why we didn't just burn it . Told them we're making garden dirt and they would roll there eyes and say no you just buy that from the store ! For a lot of rad gardeners in other places that's just normal down here it's more of an edge . heck a good bit of his success it just not being super rigid which is planting practices. Most around here will set up a plot and that's where everything has to go regardless of what that plant likes. Him ? " O it stays wet and gross over there... Egh cucumbers like that I'll toss some there .